Maria Martinez
From the Subjected Subject to the Vulnerable Subject: An
Unfinished Discussion in Contemporary Spanish Feminisms
I
n this article I discuss the question of the subject of feminism. This issue
emerges and reemerges constantly in feminist literature and activist dis-
course.
1
The subject of feminism is by no means static or consensual but
rather is a field of arguments, disagreements, transformations, and problem-
atizations that vary over time. In this article I do not aim to cover feminist and
queer theoretical discussions on the subject of feminism, which many other
theorists have already done with great quality and impact.
2
Rather, I intend
to place this question in a particular frame: the feminist movement in con-
temporary Spain. This is a particularly interesting case, since this movement
was constituted after forty years of a dictatorship that understood women as
inferior to men. While these gender hierarchies of course were not unique to
Spain, here they were part of national politics.
In Spain, the feminist movement was “born” in 1975, with the I Jornadas
de la Mujer (First national conference for women’s liberation) in Madrid,
This article was made possible thanks to the financial support of the postdoctoral program
of the Spanish Basque Government (2016–19) and of the Research Group of the Basque Uni-
versity System (IT706–13), located at the University of the Basque Country. Many people
contributed to the development of the arguments made in this article and have commented
on one or several of its passages: my PhD supervisor, Benjamín Tejerina; my dissertation com-
mittee; and the research project team “Victim(s) Worlds,” especially Gabriel Gatti, David
Casado-Neira, Sandrine Revet, and Ramón Sáez. The current version of this text owes much
to the excellent and challenging comments of the three anonymous Signs reviewers as well as
the work of the editorial team, to whom I would like to direct my thanks for the work they
put in.
1
This distinction between academic and activist feminists is merely analytical, not just be-
cause many academics are also activists but also because nonacademics straddle the border be-
tween expert knowledge and ethno-knowledge.
2
It is impossible to list all the texts that have considered this question, but works that have
had considerable impact in Spain include Alcoff (1988), Riley (1988), Nicholson (1989), But-
ler and Scott (1992), Benhabib et al. (1995), Butler (1999), and hooks et al. (2004). In Span-
ish academia, I would highlight the work done by Celia Amorós and her working group on
feminism and Enlightenment: e.g., Amorós (1997) and Amorós and de Miguel (2005). In
Johnson and Zubiaurre (2012) we find a recent review of Spanish feminist thinking where the
discussion of the subject of feminism is central.
[Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 2018, vol. 43, no. 2]
© 2017 by The University of Chicago. All rights reserved. 0097-9740/2018/4302-0004$10.00