Nigerian Journal of Engineering, Vol. 28, No. 3, December 2021, ISSN (print): 0794 – 4756, ISSN(online):2705-3954.
Nigerian Journal of Engineering,
Faculty of Engineering, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria
journal homepage: www.njeabu.com.ng
Comparative Analysis of Four Stroke and Six Stroke Internal Combustion
Renault Engine Efficiency Using Matlab Simulation Tool
I. B. Owunna
1
, A. E. Ikpe
2
1,2
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Benin, Benin – Nigeria.
1
aniekan.ikpe@eng.uniben.edu
Research Article
Abstract
This study presents a four stroke and six-stroke comparative analysis of Internal Combustion (IC) Renault engine (Mercedes-
Benz 250SE, W108 model) efficiency using MATLAB 2018b simulation tool. Using air (working fluid) as charge introduced in the
four-stroke engine, efficiency of 36.6% was achieved. However, using air as the charge introduced with a recompression stroke
occurring at the fourth stroke, efficiency of 43.2% was obtained. Using air as the charge introduced with an exhaust stroke
occurring at the fourth stroke, efficiency of 48.4% was obtained. Using water as the charge introduced with a recompression
stroke occurring at the fourth stroke, efficiency of 44.6% was obtained. Using water as the charge introduced with an exhaust
stroke occurring at the fourth stroke, efficiency of 51.5% was obtained. The results indicated that six-stroke engine has a higher
efficiency than four stroke IC engine when air is used as working fluid while the efficiency of six stroke IC engine is higher when
water is used as working fluid compared to when air is used.
Copyright © Faculty of Engineering, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria.
Keywords Article History
Efficiency; Internal combustion; Six Stroke; Four stroke; Renault
engine
Received: – April, 2021
Reviewed: – July, 2021
Accepted: – November, 2021
Published: – December, 2021
1. Introduction
Internal combustion (IC) engine is a type of engine in which the
combustion in the combustion chamber occurs internally. The
combustion of air-fuel mixture in IC engine occurs in the
combustion chamber of the engine where heat generated in the
process reacts with the air-fuel mixture to form hot gases,
thereby increasing the internal pressure within the engine
cylinder (Ikpe et al., 2016a; Ikpe et al., 2016b). The in-cylinder
pressurised air-fuel mixture gradually builds momentum at
increasing temperature starting from 293.92K. This causes
reciprocating movement of the piston which is translated to the
rotating motion of the crankshaft (Lewis, 2013; Soda, 2013). In
the process of the reciprocating piston transferring force from
expanding gas in the cylinder to the crankshaft through the
piston rod and/or connecting rod, mechanical work is achieved
(Owunna and Ikpe, 2020). After each compression cycle, the IC
engine undergo combustion followed by the expansion of the
compressed air-fuel mixture in the cylinder. Internal
combustion engines have undergone several improvements in
recent times, which have led to significant advantages in the
engine operating cycle such as relatively low initial cost, high
power density and efficiency as well as the ability to meet
emission standards (Caton, 2018; Ikpe and Owunna, 2020).
Internal combustion engines consist of various types which
includes: Two stroke engine, the four-stroke engine and the six
stroke engine. Examples of I.C engines includes; Scram jet
engines, Wankel engine, Rocket engines, Pulse Jet engines,
Ram Jet engines, Turbojet engines, Turboprop engines,
Turbofan engines, Turbo shaft engines etc. In the World today,
four stroke cycle engine is widely used in cars, heavy duty
vehicles as well as heavy duty machines, etc. These engines
consume fuel on a daily basis whose value may stretch largely
annually and as much has effect on the fuel economy. Apart
from the effect on the economy, exhaust gases released from
such engines into the environment causes pollution and also aid
in the depletion of the ozone layer by the release of greenhouse
gases. Improving efficiency of this engine is something that is
highly needed.
The six-stroke design was developed by Bruce crower, a
veteran of the racing industry and the owner of a company
which produces high performance cams and other engine parts.
However, four-stroke spark ignition (SI) engine was developed
by Nikolaou's Ottoin in 1876 (Mashkour and Ahmed, 2017).
Six stroke engine introduces two more strokes which is the fifth
and the sixth stroke making it two power strokes and two
exhaust strokes. The working fluid of this remaining two stroke
being water, makes effective use of the heat energy from the
fourth stroke to superheat the water to steam. Due to the
addition of two extra strokes, the fuel injection takes place every
sixth stroke as compared to every fourth stroke in the original
four stroke IC engine cycle (Balse et al., 2015). Therefore, fuel
consumption is reduced drastically by more than 40% which
may have large significance on the economy as the working
fluid is not just fuel alone but water as well which is readily
available and cheap (Chaulkar, 2018). A cycle of four-stroke
engines is completed by two crankshaft revolutions, while a
cycle of six-stroke engines is completed on three crankshaft
revolutions (İçingür & Arabaci, 2013). According to Arabaci
(2019), one cycle is completed in two revolutions for four-
stroke engines, while one cycle is completed in three
revolutions for six-stroke engines. This results in lower fuel
consumption for the six-stroke engine with the same engine
volume. Compared to four stroke engine, six stroke engine has
thermal efficiency reaching 50% (30% for the actual internal
combustion engines), fuel consumption reduced by more than
62