Open Access
Khan et al., 1:8
http://dx.doi.org/10.4172/scientificreports.409
Rapid Communication Open Access
Open Access Scientific Reports
Scientific Reports
Open Access
Volume 1 • Issue 8 • 2012
Te Islamic Republic of Pakistan is a developing country and has
a population of more than 171 million people [1], although it has
some large cities such as Karachi, Lahore, Peshawar and Quetta but
almost 65% of the population is still living in rural areas, with a per
capita income of $ 408 per year. Te overall literacy rate is estimated
to be 41.5% but is much lower for women particularly in small of the
provinces [1,2]. Majority of the population take advantage of the free
healthcare facility provided by the government in the public sector
hospitals and health care units due to low income, but these facilities
are generally short-stafed, congested, overburden and incompetent
which cannot meet the requirements of the people visiting these
facilities however due to poverty and lack of national health coverage
and health insurance schemes, a huge section of the population is
deprived to have even access to any healthcare facility [3,4]. According
to economic Survey 2009-2010, in Pakistan, Government has allocated
only 2.0 per cent for the education which is very less in comparison
with the other South Asian countries rather one of the lowest in the
developing countries. 65 percent of enrolled students attend the public
sector schools where education supposed to be free or less expensive.
Te quality of education in the public sector schools is usually very
poor. Te well privileged or those who can aford, go to the private
sector schools where most of the cases quality education is provided
but usually very expensive and beyond the reach of the masses, however
education in low fee private sector schools is also not satisfactory
[5]. Another segment of society who usually cannot aford to go to
school usually go the Madrasas (institutions where usually religious
education is provided) where they get free boarding and lodging along
with education. Still not all children in Pakistan are in school and yet
another majority of the children who don’t go or cannot aford to go
to any of the institutions rather they are on the streets or support their
family by earning in diferent vocational palaces. According to the
Pakistan Labor Force Survey (2007-2008), there are over 21 million
children between 10 to 14 years of age out of which 2.68 million are
employed [6]. Tere are too many local issues and problems including
terrorism, poverty, joblessness and tension on the eastern and western
borders, political and economical instability in the country. All these
and other problems put the important sectors like education and
health comparative in less priority and the government invests very
less in these areas rather spends more in defense and to control the
law and order situation in the country. Due to very less investment
in education particularly in higher education and science the research
bioethics seems to be luxury and no one speaks about this rather most
of the time the politicians and the policy makers and even masses talk
about the availability of basic needs and necessities. Bioethics or ethics
in research is usually not thought as a separate subject at college or at
university level, due which there is very less awareness and practices
among the researches and professionals. Research is mandatory
element to defne success of a nation. Te most challenging task is
maintenance of highest ethical standards in research. Research on
human subjects is very challenging in developed & under developed
countries [7]. People are less willing to participate in research subjects
unless well compensated in developed countries, this made research
very expensive compared to developing countries. So the pool of
*Corresponding author: Saeed Khan, Department of Molecular Pathology, Dow
University of Health Sciences, University Road Karachi; E-mail: saeedkhn@gmail.com,
saeed.khan@duhs.edu.pk
Received March 21, 2012; Published October 30, 2012
Citation: Khan S, Mushtaq S, Arshad N, Lone NA (2012) The Current Status of
Research Bioethics in Pakistan. 1:409. doi:10.4172/scientifcreports.409
Copyright: © 2012 Khan S, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under
the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted
use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and
source are credited.
The Current Status of Research Bioethics in Pakistan
Saeed Khan
1
*, Shamim Mushtaq
2
, Narmeen Arshad
1
and Nazir Ahmed Lone
3
1
Department of Molecular pathology, Dow University of Health Sciences (DUHS), Pakistan
2
National Center for Proteomic, University of Karachi
3
Karakoram International University, Gilgit Baltistan, Pakistan
research is diverted towards developing countries but unfortunately
outcome of the action has raised serious concerns to ensure the rights
& ethical issues being well protected [8]. Te primary aim of this
paper is to report the current status of bioethics in Pakistan and try to
propose guidelines to help to resolve controversial issues in a practical
way that would lead to both scientific and ethical progress in research
in the country. Issues administered during bioethics research unethical
application of science & modern medical technologies, collusion of
health professionals, the physician pharma nexus quiet an unholy
alliance, international organ trade & transplantation. Finally, we will
look at the need to implement guidelines in structural policy changes.
Te history of bioethics in Pakistan is a rather short one though in
our country, there is a need for a major capacity building exercise in
Bioethics and Research Bioethics. In Pakistan it is primarily members
of the medical community, many trained in Western institutions, who
take the lead in introducing modern bioethics into the country. Te
frst proper move in this direction occurred in 1984 at the Aga Khan
University (AKU) in Karachi, where biomedical ethics was introduced
in the curriculum of medical students at AKU by the Chairman of the
Department of Community Health Sciences and later extended into
the courses of the University’s School of Nursing. In Pakistan as other
developing countries, there has been a great demand for research-
ethics related programs. In 2001, the Pakistan Medical and Dental
Council (PMDC), the certifying body for all graduating physicians
and dentists, stipulated that biomedical ethics must be included in
the medical curricula. However, this is still not the case in most of the
country’s research institutions, medical colleges, universities and many
still limit themselves to a few informative lectures on the subject during
rotation of students through community health sciences. In January
2004 the Pakistani government approved the formation of the National
Bioethics Committee with 20–21 members chaired by the Director
General of Health at the Ministry of Health. Whereas the Centre of
Biomedical Ethics and Culture (CBEC) is the frst such Centre in
Pakistan established in 2004 in SIUT (Sindh Institute of Urology and
Transplantation) which conducts Master courses in Bioethics and
plays its role to promote bioethical education, research and training
in Pakistan [9].
To date the AKU Hospital is the only institution with a formal
ethics consultation service, which is one of the functions of its
Hospital Ethics Committee (HEC), initiated in 2000 [10]. Te Eastern
Mediterranean Regional Organization (EMRO) of WHO has also