PHYSICAL REVIEW E 95, 013103 (2017)
Friction factor for aerosol fractal aggregates over the entire Knudsen range
James Corson,
1
George W. Mulholland,
1
and Michael R. Zachariah
1, 2, *
1
Department of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, University of Maryland, College Park, Maryland 20742, USA
2
Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, University of Maryland, College Park, Maryland 20742, USA
(Received 29 September 2016; published 4 January 2017)
We develop an approach for computing the hydrodynamic friction tensor and scalar friction coefficient for
an aerosol fractal aggregate in the transition regime. Our approach involves solving the Bhatnagar-Gross-Krook
equation for the velocity field around a sphere and using the velocity field to calculate the force on each primary
sphere in the aggregate due to the presence of the other spheres. It is essentially an extension of Kirkwood-Riseman
theory from the continuum flow regime to the entire Knudsen range (Knudsen number from 0.01 to 100 based on
the primary sphere radius). Our results compare well to published direct simulation Monte Carlo results, and they
converge to the correct continuum and free molecule limits. Our calculations for clusters with up to 100 spheres
support the theory that aggregate slip correction factors collapse to a single curve when plotted as a function of
an appropriate aggregate Knudsen number. This self-consistent-field approach calculates the friction coefficient
very quickly, so the approach is well-suited for testing existing scaling laws in the field of aerosol science and
technology, as we demonstrate for the adjusted sphere scaling method.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevE.95.013103
I. INTRODUCTION
Aerosol fractal aggregates formed from the coagulation of
smaller, spherical primary particles are found in many natural
and industrial settings. Understanding the forces on these
aggregates is important in a number of science and engineering
disciplines, including combustion, fire safety, atmospheric and
environmental sciences, materials engineering [1], and nuclear
reactor safety [2]. The translational drag force for a particle
moving slowly relative to the surrounding fluid—given by
F =−ζ U
0
, where U
0
is the particle’s relative velocity and ζ is
the orientation-averaged scalar friction factor—is particularly
important because it influences the transport properties of
the particle, including its diffusion coefficient and electrical
mobility.
In many practical applications, the primary sphere radius a
is significantly less than the mean free path of the surrounding
gas (λ ≈ 65 nm at standard temperature and pressure and an
order of magnitude higher near a flame), so that the primary
sphere is in or near the free molecule flow regime. At the same
time, the radius of gyration R
g
for the agglomerate may be
comparable to or larger than the mean free path, so that the
aggregate is in the transition flow regime. As one example, for
carbonaceous soot a ≈ 5–30 nm and R
g
≈ 30–1000 nm.
There are a number of theories and techniques for com-
puting the translational friction factor of macromolecules
and particle aggregates in the continuum regime, including
Kirkwood-Riseman (KR) theory [3] and its extensions by
Rotne and Prager [4], Yamakawa [5], and Chen et al. [6], as
well as algorithms that use the Hubbard and Douglas analogy
between the electrostatic capacitance and the friction factor
[7–9]. Likewise, there are established methods for computing
ζ in the free molecule regime that simulate the ballistic nature
of interactions between gas molecules and aggregates [10–13].
In contrast, there are few approaches for the transition
regime. Melas et al. [14] estimated the friction coefficient
*
mrz@umd.edu
in the near-continuum regime by solving the Laplace equation
with a slip boundary condition at the surface of the particle. In
a followup paper, the authors determined that their collision
rate method is valid for Knudsen numbers less than 2 [15].
Dahneke [16] developed the adjusted sphere method for
the transition regime, which applies a slip correction factor to
the continuum friction factor. The key to this development
is the identification of an aggregate Knudsen number that
reduces a problem involving two length scales (primary radius
and aggregate radius of gyration) to a single dimensionless
length. Dahneke’s approach is similar to the approach used
to calculate the drag on a sphere in the transition regime,
but the adjusted sphere method uses an adjusted Knudsen
number based on geometric descriptions of the particle in
the continuum (hydrodynamic radius, R
H
) and free molecular
[projected area (PA)] regimes.
Through scaling analysis, Zhang et al. [17] developed
an approach analogous to the adjusted sphere method and
demonstrated that the approach yields friction factors com-
parable to direct simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) results for
the aggregates they studied (spheres, dimers, and dense and
open 20-particle aggregates). However, it requires knowledge
of the hydrodynamic radius and the projected area of the
particle, which may take tens of minutes to a few hours to
obtain computationally for a single particle. Obtaining R
H
and PA experimentally is possible, but it requires painstaking
transmission electron microscopy (TEM) measurements [18].
More rigorous computational techniques for calculating the
transition regime friction factor—such as DSMC or molecular
dynamics—are time-consuming: for instance, the reported
DSMC calculation times in Ref. [17] were on the order of
one CPU week for a given Knudsen number and a given
aggregate. Thus, a self-consistent-field theory method for
quickly estimating the scalar friction factor of an aggregate
across the Knudsen range is highly desirable.
In this paper, we present an approach for computing
the hydrodynamic friction tensor H and the scalar friction
coefficient ζ for fractal aggregates across the entire Knudsen
range. Our approach involves solving for the velocity field
2470-0045/2017/95(1)/013103(6) 013103-1 ©2017 American Physical Society