ARTICLE
Understanding visual metaphor: the
example of newspaper cartoons
ELISABETH EL REFAIE
University of Plymouth
ABSTRACT
Using Austrian newspaper cartoons as examples, this article explores the
‘grammar’ of visual metaphor. It is argued that visual metaphors cannot be
described adequately in formal terms only. Rather, they must be
considered as visual representations of metaphorical thoughts or
concepts. A cognitive definition of metaphor must not, however, distract
from potential variations in meaning and impact arising from the mode of
communication through which metaphors are expressed. This study
suggests that many of the dissimilarities between verbal metaphor and its
visual counterpart result from differences regarding what the two modes
are able to express easily and efficiently.
KEY WORDS
Austrian newspapers • cartoons • cognitive metaphor theory • refugees •
visual metaphor
INTRODUCTION
The aim of this article is to explore the ways in which metaphors are
expressed in the visual mode, more specifically in newspaper cartoons. I use
the analysis of caricatures from Austrian daily newspapers in order to
demonstrate three central arguments, each of which forms the basis of one of
the article’s three sections. First, I suggest that visual metaphors are best
described in terms of their underlying metaphorical concepts. This view of
visual metaphors as the pictorial expression of a metaphorical way of
thinking is congruent with the main tenets of cognitive metaphor theory.
My second argument is that such a definition of visual metaphors in
cognitive terms is not as straightforward as it seems, because the boundaries
between the literal and the metaphorical are fuzzy and highly context-
dependent. This means that metaphors must always be studied within their
socio-political context.
Copyright © 2003 SAGE Publications (London, Thousand Oaks, CA
and New Delhi: www.sagepublications.com)
Vol 2(1): 75–95 [1470-3572(200302)2:1; 75–95;029755]
visual communication