Jan Haspeslagh = username
157.193.5.81 = IP address
Fri, 26 Apr 2013 20:56:27 = Date & Time
Environment and History 19 (2013): 209–232
© 2013 The White Horse Press. doi: 10.3197/096734013X13642082568651
Flood Security in the Medieval and Early Modern
North Sea Area: A Question of Entitlement?
TIM SOENS
Department of History
University of Antwerp
Prinsstraat 13 (D313), B-2000 Antwerp, Belgium
Email: tim.soens@ua.ac.be
ABSTRACT
Starting in the later Middle Ages, the coastal wetlands along the southern
North Sea area were increasingly hit by a series of catastrophic storm surges.
Deeply rooted in the collective memory of coastal society, these food disasters
are mostly discussed as products of meteorological disturbances, environmen-
tal vulnerability or technological failure. In this article, an alternative reading
is proposed, drawing attention to massive distortions in the social allocation of
food protection in the later Middle Ages, which help to explain the increased
frequency of storm disasters. Building on Amartya Sen’s original entitlement
approach, it is argued that the right of coastal peasants to food security often
witnessed severe setbacks preceding many food disasters, caused by adverse
economic conditions, but also by an increasing violation of their entitlement to
food protection mainly by non-peasant groups, backed by an expanding state
power.
KEYWORDS
Environmental disaster, water management, food risk, entitlement
INTRODUCTION: EXPLAINING THE AGE OF STORMS IN THE LATER
MIDDLE AGES
All over the North Sea Area the later Middle Ages saw repeated food disasters
and massive land losses in coastal wetlands: in England, the Low Countries,
Northern Germany and Southern Scandinavia thousands of hectares of re-
claimed land and hundreds of villages were lost to the sea. For instance, in
the Scheldt Estuary in the present-day province of Zeeland (The Netherlands),