ACCEPTED FOR PUBLICATION ON IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON GEOSCIENCE AND REMOTE SENSING
1
Land CSEM simulations and experimental test
using metallic casing in a geothermal exploration
context: Vall` es Basin (NE Spain) case study
Octavio Castillo-Reyes, Pilar Queralt, Alex Marcuello, Juanjo Ledo
Abstract—Controlled-source electromagnetic (CSEM) mea-
surements are complementary data for magnetotelluric (MT)
characterization, although its methodology on land is not suf-
ficiently developed and tested as in marine environments. Ac-
quiring expertise in CSEM is crucial for surveys in places where
MT cannot be performed due to high-levels of cultural noise.
To acquire that expertise, we perform CSEM experiments in the
Vall` es fault (Northeast (NE), Spain) where MT results have been
satisfactory and allow us to verify the CSEM results. The Vall` es
basin is relevant for potential heat generation because of the
presence of several geothermal anomalies, and its nearby location
to urban areas. In this paper, we present the experimental setup
for that region, a 2-D joint MT+CSEM inverse model, several
3-D CSEM simulations in the presence of metallic casing, and its
comparison with real data measurements. We employ a parallel
and high-order vector finite element algorithm to discretize the
governing equations. By using an adapted meshing strategy,
different scenarios are simulated to study the influence of the
source position/direction and the conductivity model in a metallic
casing presence. An excellent agreement between simulated data
and analytical/real field data demonstrates the feasibility of study
metallic structures in realistic configurations. Our numerical
results confirm that metallic casing strongly influences electro-
magnetic responses, making surface measurements more sensitive
to resistivity variations near the metallic structure. It could be
beneficial getting higher signal-to-noise ratios and sensitivity to
deep targets. However, such casing effect depends on the input
model (e.g., conductivity contrasts, frequency, and geometry).
Index Terms—Controlled-source electromagnetic (CSEM), nu-
merical modeling, metallic casing effects, high-performance com-
puting, geothermal exploration.
I. I NTRODUCTION
O
VER the last 20 years, electromagnetic (EM) methods
have become invaluable research tools in geophysics
with rapidly increasing applications in both industry and
academia. Both active and passive EM methods can improve
the characterization and interpretation of geophysical datasets
by mapping conductivity variations, and reducing ambiguities
during exploration surveys. In this sense, the CSEM has
become more and more popular in many different application
scenarios due to its ability to display conductivity contrasts
with respect to their surrounding sediments (e.g., detecting
resistive zones in a conductive background). As a result,
Octavio Castillo-Reyes is with Barcelona Supercomputing Center (BSC),
Nexus II Building c/Jordi Girona 29, 08034, Barcelona (Spain),
Tel.: +34 934 137 992
octavio.castillo@bsc.es (corresponding author)
Pilar Queralt, Alex Marcuello and Juanjo Ledo are with
Institut Geomodels, Departament de Din` amica de la Terra i de l’Oce` a
Universitat de Barcelona, 08028 Barcelona, Spain
nowadays CSEM has real application in many contexts such as
hydrocarbon exploration [1]–[10], reservoir monitoring [11],
[12], CO
2
storage characterization [13]–[18], and geothermal
reservoir imaging [19]–[22], among others.
In marine exploration contexts, CSEM plays a fundamental
role in the geological characterization of faults and reservoirs,
and allow monitoring the latter due to its high sensitivity
to fluid movements and to useful buried resources. In these
scenarios, CSEM is a well established supplementing tech-
nique to MT [23]–[25]. Also, marine CSEM has provided
valuable complementary information to seismic imaging, and
has been also used for setting up seismic inversions. However,
in land-based exploration environments, CSEM applications
for imaging conductivity contrasts among targets and neigh-
bouring materials are scarce, since CSEM needs very different
data acquisition and processing strategies [26], [27]. Usually,
regions of interest are urbanized and industrialized areas
(e.g., railways, power grid, telephone networks, and indus-
trial facilities). Consequently, human-generated noise prevents
passive methods such as MT, which is a strong limitation
for relevant land-based applications, such as CO
2
storage
and geothermal exploration. Numerical simulation tools allow
us to reproduce different materials’ responses to external
excitation to analyze observed data and infer models of the
subsurface as correct as possible. These simulations have been
proven to validate geological models by direct comparison
between data and synthetics in different application fields. In
the case of land CSEM, these modeling codes are essential
to understand the effect of metallic infrastructures and to
study their use to improving the signal-to-noise ratio. The
analysis of these effects has gained traction recently, and
many different approaches have been evaluated on differ-
ent application contexts. Out of these applications, studies
in the area of energy reservoir modeling [28]–[33], water
flooding [34], [35], geological storage [36]–[38], geothermal
exploration [39], [40], and fractures and fault zones [41],
[42], stand out. Regardless of numerical methodology or
application area, these works stress out the significant effects
on EM responses generated by the presence of steel-cased
wells and other metallic infrastructure. Also, authors affirm
that CSEM modeling in the presence of metallic structures
present a numerically challenging problem because of two
main reasons. Firstly, the considerable conductivity contrast
between surrounding media and metallic casing. Secondly,
the large-scale variation of target bodies requires different
resolution levels of discretization. Consequently, simulation
“© 2021 IEEE. Personal use of this material is permitted. Permission from IEEE must be obtained for all other uses, in any current or future media, including reprinting/republishing this material for
advertising or promotional purposes, creating new collective works, for resale or redistribution to servers or lists, or reuse of any copyrighted component of this work in other works.”