216 Journal of Applied Solution Chemistry and Modeling, 2013, 2, 216-224
E-ISSN: 1929-5030/13 © 2013 Lifescience Global
Ab Initio and Density Functional Predictions of Solvation Free
Energies of Cyclic Polyethers (CH
2
CH
2
O)
n
(n=2,6) in Aqueous and
Tetrachloromethane Solutions
B. Ariche
1,2,*
, A. Rahmouni
1
, H. Brahim
1
, A. Guendouzi
1
and K. Alali
1
1
Modeling and Calculation Methods Laboratory, Taher Moulay University, B.P. 138, En-Nasr Avenue,
Mascara Road, 20002 Saida, Algeria
2
Department of Chemistry, University of Oran 1, PO Box 1524 Elmnaouer, Oran 31000, Algeria
Abstract: Solvation free energies G
sol
tot of cyclic polyethers (CH2CH2O)n (n=2,6) in aqueous and tetrachloromethane
solutions have been calculated at HF, MP2 and B3LYP/6-311G (d,p) levels of theory using CPCM, IEFPCM and SMD
implicit solvation models. It has been found that G
sol
tot are negative for both solvents, they increase linearly with system
sizes and they are more important in water solution. The electrostatic contributions to the solvation free energies G
sol
ele
are also more important in water because of their polar nature. In water, CPCM and IEFPCM models give a close
values, which are slightly different from SMD values. In tetrachloromethane solvent CPCM model seems overestimate
G
sol
ele. For both solvents the non-electrostatic contributions to the solvation free energies G
sol
n-ele provided by SMD are
remarkably different to those given by CPCM and IEFPCM models.
Keywords: Continuum model, Solvation free energy, Cyclic polyether, Water, Tetrachloromethane.
1. INTRODUCTION
Many theoretical studies have been performed to
understand the solvation of crown ethers in liquid
phases [1-5]. Continuum solvation model is one of the
powerful tools to provide accurate estimates of
solvation free energies at a reasonable computational
cost [6-22]. Compared to the explicit solvation model
arranging a few solvent molecules around the solute,
the continuum model places a solute molecule in a
solvent cavity surrounded by a polarizable continuum,
whose reaction field modifies the energy and properties
of the solute. Hence, the calculations using the
continuum solvation model are cheaper, simpler, and
more convenient than those using the explicit solvation
model [23].
Conductor-like polarizable continuum model
(CPCM) [13,16] and integral equation formalism
polarizable continuum model (IEFPCM) [7-12] are two
of many successful solvation models. In their
approaches, the solute interacts with the solvent
represented by a dielectric continuum model. The
solute molecule is embedded into a cavity surrounded
by a dielectric continuum of a given permittivity. CPCM
and IEFPCM define the cavities as envelopes of
spheres centered on atoms or atomic groups. Inside
the cavity the dielectric constant is the same as in
vacuo, outside it takes the value of the desired solvent.
*Address correspondence to this author at the Modeling and Calculation
Methods Laboratory, Taher Moulay University, B.P. 138, En-nasr Avenue,
Mascara Road, 20002 Saida, Algeria; Tel/Fax: +21348471508;
E-mail: berkane.ariche@univ-saida.dz
Once the cavity has been defined, the surface is
smoothly mapped by small regions, called tesserae.
Each tessera is characterized by the position of its
centre, its area, and the electrostatic vector normal to
the surface passing through its centre. Unlike the
previous models, universal solvation model based on
solute electron density (SMD) [20,21] is based on the
quantum mechanical charge density of a solute
molecule interacting with continuum description of the
solvent. The SMD bulk electrostatic contribution to the
free energy of solvation arises from a self-consistent
reaction field treatment that involves solution of the
nonhomogeneous Poisson equation by the Integral-
Equation-Formalism Polarizable Continuum Model [20].
Cyclic polyethers (CH
2
CH
2
O)
n
, commonly known as
crown ethers [24], are synthesized originally by
Pederson in 1967 [25]. They exhibit conformational
mobility and have the structure of a cavity that is lined
inside with the electron pairs of the donor atoms and
surrounded from the outside by the hydrocarbon
framework [26]. The principal interest of crown ethers
arises from their potential to form stable complexes
with a wide variety of ionic and neutral species [27-36].
This property is the basis of their broad practical
applications in various areas of inorganic and organic
chemistry, chemical fertilizers and pesticides,
metallurgy, nuclear energy, biology, pharmacology and
medicine [37,38].
Several thermodynamic studies of crown ethers
solvation and complexation have recently appeared
[3,26,39-44], investigation of solvation and association
states of such important macrocycle ligands can help to