Journal of Power Electronics, Vol. 17, No. 4, pp. 1097-1108, July 2017 1097
https://doi.org/10.6113/JPE.2017.17.4.1097
ISSN(Print): 1598-2092 / ISSN(Online): 2093-4718
JPE 17-4-24
Applicable Method for Average Switching Loss
Calculation in Power Electronic Converters
Seyyed Abbas Saremi Hasari
*
, Ahmad Salemnia
†
, and Mohsen Hamzeh
*
*, †
Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
Accurate calculation of the conduction and switching losses of a power electronic converter is required to achieve the efficiency of
the converter. Such calculation is also useful for computing the junction temperature of the switches. A few models have been
developed in the articles for calculating the switching energy losses during switching transitions for the given values of switched
voltage and switched current. In this study, these models are comprehensively reviewed and investigated for the first time for ease of
comparison among them. These models are used for calculating the average amount of switching power losses. However, some points
and details should be considered in utilizing these models when switched current or switched voltage presents time-variant and
alternative quantity. Therefore, an applicable technique is proposed in details to use these models under the above-mentioned
conditions. A proper switching loss model and the presented technique are used to establish a new and fast method for obtaining the
average switching power losses in any type of power electronic converters. The accuracy of the proposed method is evaluated by
comprehensive simulation studies and experimental results.
Key words: Analytical loss model, Conduction loss model, Power electronic converter loss, Switching loss model
I. INTRODUCTION
Power electronic converters play an important role in the
electric power industry because of their applications, such as
integrating the distributed energy units into the grid [1],
improving the power quality of the grid [2], and driving the
electric motors. Electrical power loss is an important concern of
power electronic converters. Converter losses usually involve
the power losses of the electromagnetic devices and the power
losses of the semiconductor switches. Switch power losses
consist of three parts: 1) switching losses, 2) conduction losses,
and 3) negligible off-state losses.
The switching losses are dominant losses at high switching
frequencies and depend on four factors [3]: 1) switched voltage,
2) switched current, 3) switching frequency, and 4) rising and
falling times of the switch voltage and current. The switching
losses are more difficult to calculate, in comparison with the
conduction losses [4]. The difficulty is attributed to the tiny
amount of the turn-on and turn-off transition times, and the
estimation of switch waveforms during transition times that
needs to provide the accurate model of the switch.
Calculating the conduction and switching losses of a power
electronic converter is useful for 1) calculating the junction
temperature of the switches for designing the heat sink, and 2)
obtaining the efficiency of the converter. Efficiency is an
important characteristic of power electronic converters and is
thus used as an evaluation criterion for five types of DC/AC
converters in [5], for two types of AC/AC converters in [6], and
for photovoltaic inverters in [7].
The switching losses of the converters can be calculated by
three methods [8], [9]: 1) utilizing experimental switching
waveforms acquired from the laboratory prototype, 2) utilizing
simulation models obtained by the switch datasheet and its
electrical and thermal models, and 3) using analytical models.
Unlike the analytical methods, simulation-based methods
require calculating the switching energy losses for all the
turn-on and turn-off transitions. Analytical methods can be
derived when the output current is sinusoidal. In these methods,
the average switching power loss is calculated using some
information, such as switch characteristics, output displacement
factor, amplitude of the output current, and modulation index.
Therefore, simulation-based methods exhibit more
computational burden compared to analytical methods.
However, simulation-based methods can be implemented for all
kinds of converters and output currents.
Manuscript received Oct. 3, 2016; accepted May 8, 2017
Recommended for publication by Associate Editor Hyung-Min Ryu.
†
Corresponding Author: a_salemnia@sbu.ac.ir
Tel: +982173932502, Fax: +982177310425, Shahid Beheshti University
*
Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Shahid Beheshti University, Iran
© 2017 KIPE