ACADEMIA Letters
The rise of public servant organizations in Puerto Rico in
the 20th Century
Carlos Carrión-Crespo
This article summarizes the fndings of my PhD Dissertation on the development of collective
action by government workers in Puerto Rico. Collective conficts arise in an institutional con-
text because, as Müller-Entsch argues,[1] institutions establish the parameters within which
actors operate, while cultural ideas and the interests of actors construct institutions. Collective
bargaining is one such institution, which we defne as a process in which two or more parties
exchange proposals on an issue with a view to reaching an agreement. When the interests
discussed involve a group of workers with common elements that defne their group identity,
they bargain collectively. The International Labour Organization (ILO) classifes collective
bargaining as a form of social dialogue, separate from and at a higher level of discourse than
information-sharing and consultations.
Jorge Rosenbaum Rimolo describes collective bargaining in its origins as “an action di-
rected by certain actors that enable to establish social work regulations in the industrial world
on the basis of an application and enforcement voluntary or conditioned by means of pressure
inherent collective action,”[2] but later became dependent on positive law systems rather than
an autonomous sociological institution.
Collective bargaining is a relatively recent phenomenon in the public service. It has been
the focus of many debates, particularly in light of the reluctance of governments to share the
power to determine working conditions of public servants. One of these debates addresses
whether collective bargaining exists where no enabling law compels the parties to discuss
specifc subjects or to set their agreements in writing, as was increasingly the case in the
private sector since the turn of the 20th century.
The discourses and institutions that shaped the exchanges between the Puerto Rican gov-
ernment and Puerto Rican government employees regarding working conditions illustrate this.
Academia Letters, August 2021
Corresponding Author: Carlos Carrión-Crespo, carrion-crespo@ilo.org
Citation: Carrión-Crespo, C. (2021). The rise of public servant organizations in Puerto Rico in the 20th
Century. Academia Letters, Article 2550. https://doi.org/10.20935/AL2550.
1
©2021 by the author — Open Access — Distributed under CC BY 4.0