Modeling of Two-Phase Behavior in the Gas Diffusion Medium
of PEFCs via Full Morphology Approach
Volker Paul Schulz,
a,z
Jürgen Becker,
a
Andreas Wiegmann,
a
Partha P. Mukherjee,
b,
*
and Chao-Yang Wang
b,
**
a
Fraunhofer-Institut für Techno- und Wirtschaftsmathematik (ITWM), Kaiserslautern, Germany
b
Electrochemical Engine Center (ECEC), and Department of Mechanical and Nuclear Engineering, The
Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA 16802, USA
A full morphology FM model has been developed for studying the two-phase characteristics of the gas diffusion medium in a
polymer electrolyte fuel cell PEFC. The three-dimensional 3D fibrous microstructure for the nonwoven gas diffusion layer
GDL microstructure has been reconstructed using a stochastic technique for Toray090 and SGL10BA carbon papers. The FM
model directly solves for the capillary pressure-saturation relations on the detailed morphology of the reconstructed GDL from
drainage simulations. The estimated capillary pressure-saturation curves can be used as valuable inputs to macroscopic two-phase
models. Additionally, 3D visualization of the water distribution in the gas diffusion medium suggests that only a small number of
pores are occupied by liquid water at breakthrough. Based on a reduced compression model, the two-phase behavior of the GDL
under mechanical load is also investigated and the capillary pressure-saturation relations are evaluated for different compression
levels.
© 2007 The Electrochemical Society. DOI: 10.1149/1.2472547 All rights reserved.
Manuscript submitted July 11, 2006; revised manuscript received December 13, 2006. Available electronically February 21, 2007.
The polymer electrolyte fuel cells PEFCs, which convert the
chemical energy of hydrogen directly into electrical energy, are con-
sidered as the most promising alternative energy-conversion devices
in the 21st century for several applications including automotive,
stationary and portable power. The electrochemical reaction occur-
ring in the cathode catalyst layer CL, referred to as the oxygen
reduction reaction combines protons, resulting from hydrogen oxi-
dation in the anode catalyst layer, with oxygen to produce water and
waste heat. Although tremendous progress has been made in recent
years in enhancing overall performance of the PEFC, one major
performance-limiting step is the coverage of the reaction sites in the
CLs as well as the blockage of the reactant-transporting networks in
the porous gas diffusion layers GDLs due to liquid water, which
hinders the oxidant from reaching the active reaction sites in the
CLs at high current density operation. The GDL plays a crucial role
in the overall water management which requires a delicate balance
between reactant transport from the gas channels and water removal
from the electrochemically active sites. Mathias et al.
1
provided a
comprehensive overview of GDL structure and functions.
Several studies have been attempted in recent years to model
two-phase behavior and flooding phenomena in polymer electrolyte
fuel cells in various degrees of complexities.
2-15
Recent reviews by
Wang
16
and Weber and Newman
17
provide comprehensive overview
of various two-phase PEFC models and address the water manage-
ment issue with particular attention to GDL in significant details.
However, all of the above-mentioned macroscopic two-phase mod-
els are plagued with the scarcity of realistic two-phase correlations,
in terms of capillary pressure and relative permeability as functions
of water saturation, tailored specifically for actual gas diffusion me-
dium characterized by woven or nonwoven fibrous structures. Due
to the lack of reliable two phase correlations, these models often
deploy a generic curve-fitted capillary pressure-saturation data origi-
nally obtained by Udell
18
in the form of Leverett-J function from
imbibition in water-wet unconsolidated sand.
19
In order to enhance
the fidelity of the two-phase computational fuel cell dynamics mod-
els, it is imperative to investigate the interplay between underlying
microstructure and two-phase characteristics of the porous gas dif-
fusion medium in polymer electrolyte fuel cells.
Recently, Gostick et al.
20
reported capillary pressure-saturation
data for various GDL materials from drainage experiments using
standard porosimetry technique. However, hardly any modeling ef-
forts in estimating two-phase characteristics of the GDL in terms of
capillary pressure as a function of liquid water saturation have been
reported in the literature.
In the present study, digital computer models of nonwoven car-
bon paper GDLs are reconstructed using a stochastic generation
method
21,22
with structural inputs, namely fiber diameter, fiber ori-
entation, and porosity, obtained from two-dimensional scanning
electron microscopy SEM micrographs of the GDL and related
available data from literature. A full morphology FM model
23-25
is
subsequently developed, which is again the attempt to investigate
two-phase behavior in the reconstructed GDL microstructures by
simulating a drainage process. Capillary pressure as function of liq-
uid water saturation is estimated for two different nonwoven GDL
materials. The capillary pressure correlations predicted by the FM
model are subsequently compared with experimental data available
in the literature.
20
Furthermore, the effect of cell clamping pressure
on the two-phase characteristics of a carbon paper GDL is investi-
gated. The importance of clamping pressure on fuel cell perfor-
mance has been studied by several researchers. Notable works in-
clude Mathias et al.,
1
Wilde et al.,
26
and Ihonen et al..
27
Mathias et
al.
1
reported compression and flexural behavior of carbon paper and
carbon cloth GDLs and indicated the effect of compressive charac-
teristics on the channel flow-field pressure drop. Wilde et al.
26
stud-
ied the impact of compression force on the GDL properties, namely
electrical resistivity, pore size, and permeability for different mate-
rials and briefly described the resulting influence on PEFC perfor-
mance. Ihonen and co-workers,
27
on the other hand, tried to assess
experimentally the influence of clamping pressure on the flooding
behavior of the GDL. However, none of these studies focused on the
dependency of capillary pressure-saturation relation on clamping
pressure through its tight coupling on the underlying GDL structure.
In the present study, we report the variation of two-phase correla-
tions in terms of capillary pressure-water saturation relation for the
GDL with various levels of cell compression. Finally, the predictive
capability of the present model in estimating realistic two-phase
correlations for input into macroscopic two-phase fuel cell dynamics
models is emphasized.
Experimental
The construction of a realistic GDL pore morphology is the es-
sential prerequisite for unveiling the influence of the underlying
structure on the two-phase behavior. This can be achieved either by
three-dimensional 3D volume imaging or by constructing a digital
microstructure based on stochastic models. Noninvasive experimen-
tal techniques, such as X-ray and magnetic resonance computed
* Electrochemical Society Student Member.
** Electrochemical Society Active Member.
z
E-mail: volker.schulz@itwm.fraunhofer.de
Journal of The Electrochemical Society, 154 4 B419-B426 2007
0013-4651/2007/1544/B419/8/$20.00 © The Electrochemical Society
B419