Children’s drawings as a self-report measurement
Liat Hamama and Tammie Ronen
Bob Shapell School of Social Work, Tel-Aviv University, Israel
ABSTRACT
The present exploratory paper addresses school-aged children’s
assessments of treatment outcomes using drawing as a self-report
measure with usefulness for assessment and therapy. The process of
using drawing in therapy can provide information on how a particular
child perceives and conceives his or her own world. Examples are
presented of drawings by three children with oppositional defiant
disorder aged 10–11 years who participated in group intervention
aiming to reduce aggressive behaviour. All three were asked to draw
themselves twice on the same day at the end of treatment: (1) a
retrospective drawing of themselves as they had been at the beginning
of intervention; and (2) a drawing of themselves as they were now,
after intervention. Children then described what they had drawn,
revealing the change they perceived. Drawing as a self-report
measure added information regarding: the child’s ability for self-
awareness; the link between thoughts, emotions and behaviours; and
the process of change.
Correspondence:
Liat Hamama,
Bob Shapell School of Social Work,
Tel-Aviv University,
Ramat Aviv 69978,
Israel
E-mail: liat-ha@zahav.net.il
Keywords: assessment, drawing,
self-report
Accepted for publication: August 2008
INTRODUCTION
Clinical practice with children dictates that therapists’
decisions about whether, when and how to intervene
should be informed by the best currently available
evidence about the effects of such interventions.
Towards this end, data from client opinion can be
useful in understanding elements of the helping
process (Macdonald 2001).
How to assess children, what measurements are
valid and reliable, who is the best assessor and what is
the role of self-report are few of the questions that
should be considered when intervening with children
(Kazdin 2000; Fongay et al. 2002; Kazdin & Weisz
2003). The present exploratory paper addresses those
questions by using children’s drawing as a clinical
self-report to measure the change processes experi-
enced while terminating 12 sessions of group therapy
based on a cognitive-behavioural model for increasing
self-control skills and reducing aggression (Ronen &
Rosenbaum 2001).
ISSUES IN ASSESSMENT AND
INTERVENTION
The kinds of assessments used and the role of those
assessments in intervention generally vary in accor-
dance with several issues, the most crucial of which
are the interventionists’ underlying theoretical orien-
tation, the identity of the source who supplies the
information, and therapeutic considerations.
Theoretical considerations
Different theories rely on different components of
assessment and evaluation. For example, in psycho-
analytic therapy, assessment aims to gauge the child’s
developmental level on a variety of dimensions such as
basic cognitive processes, object relations, personality
structure, conflicts and fears, capacity for empathy,
and coping resources (Tuma & Russ 1993). In behav-
ioural therapy, assessment is based on: direct observa-
tion of the child’s behaviour and interaction within
his or her environment; scales and questionnaires to
attain information about specific skills, resources and
behaviours; and/or self-recordings of specific, clearly
The authors would like to express their gratitude to Dee B.
Ankonina for her editorial assistance.
doi:10.1111/j.1365-2206.2008.00585.x
90 Child and Family Social Work 2009, 14, pp 90–102 © 2009 The Authors
Journal compilation © 2009 Blackwell Publishing Ltd