2004-01-2574
Jet Fuel Vapor Ignition within a Duct Thermal Insulation
Guilherme Araújo Lima da Silva
Ricardo José Barbosa
Embraer S.A. – Empresa Brasileira de Aeronáutica
Euryale Jorge Godoy de Jesus Zerbini
Integral Engenharia, Estudos e Projetos
Escola Politécnica da Universidade de São Paulo
Copyright © 2004 SAE International
ABSTRACT
A test setup was built to identify the ignition of jet fuel
vapor-air mixtures within an insulation media and
induced by a hot duct surface. The external diameter of
the duct was 76.2 mm (3 inches) and covered with a
12.7 mm (0.5 inch) layer of ceramic fiber insulation,
which had its pores completely filled with fuel vapor and
air mixtures. The ignition was detected by thermocouples
installed in insulation media and confirmed by
chromatography and mass spectrometry. In order to
design the experimental apparatus and allow behavior
investigation in other operational conditions, a
mathematical model was developed.
INTRODUCTION
A combustible mixture can be ignited spontaneously and
almost simultaneously through its volume if it is heated to
a certain temperature. According to ASTM E 659-78
definition, autoignition is the lowest temperature to which
a combustible mixture must be raised so that the rate of
heat generated by the exothermic oxidation reactions will
over-balance the rate of heat transfer to surroundings
and cause ignition
1
. On the other hand, external agents
like electrical discharge; heat transfer from hot surfaces
to the combustible mixture and pilot flames can induce a
forced or non-spontaneous ignition.
In aircraft environmental control system installations, the
hot and compressed engine bleed air is delivered to the
pneumatic users, such as environmental control unit
packs and airfoil ice protection systems, by a duct
network that extends along aircraft.
Some system installations may have bleed ducting
passing through zones in the neighborhood of a fuel tank
that can have fuel vapor in some concentration. A jet fuel
vapor ignition process will be initiated by a hot surface of
a bleed system ducting, or component, if the heat
transfer from the hot surface cause enough increase of
fuel vapor-air mixture temperature.
Several factors can influence a hot-surface ignition such
as geometry, heat transfer by radiation, convection and
conduction, properties of the fluid near the wall, chemical
kinetics. The threshold ignition temperatures can be
compared only when considering similar installations,
operational and environmental conditions
1, 2
.
In the 60´s, the Royal Aircraft Establishment (RAE)
performed an original and extensive research program to
investigate the ignition of aircraft fuels. Cansdale and
Macdonald
3
continued and extended the research work
covering the fuel liquid and vapor ignition developed at
RAE.
In previous researches, Macdonald and White
4
tested
kerosene fuel vapor ignition inside uniformly heated
vessels and Macdonald
5
investigated ignition promoted
by hot ducts. In the last reference, the ducts were placed
horizontally into a spherical enclosure with controlled wall
temperatures and filled with fuel and air mixtures.
Botteri et al edited a comprehensive review of aircraft fire
safety issues, including fuel vapor ignition
6
, as result of
NATO´s AGARD Propulsion and Energetics Panel
Working Group 11 tasks.
OBJECTIVE
The main objective was to investigate the jet fuel vapor-
air mixture ignition phenomena induced by a hot surface
within a duct thermal insulation. The ignition occurrence
characterization was performed with the measurement of
temperature profile distortion promoted by the reaction
processes in the duct insulation media. Therefore, the
intention was to start exploring the subject in order to
provide insights for future works, indicate trends, and
discuss practices but not to define any criteria for design.