~ 250 ~
International Journal of Sanskrit Research 2020; 6(5): 250-257
ISSN: 2394-7519
IJSR 2020; 6(5): 250-257
© 2020 IJSR
www.anantaajournal.com
Received: 08-07-2020
Accepted: 12-08-2020
Mahesh U Patil
Thane, Maharashtra,
India
Corresponding Author:
Mahesh U Patil
Thane, Maharashtra,
India
Legend descent of Ganga and similarities with impact
event
Mahesh U Patil
DOI: https://doi.org/10.22271/23947519.2020.v6.i5e.1148
Abstract
Role of comets and icy asteroids in getting water to Earth is under discussion for last few decades. In the
recent history, we have observed and recorded two comet impact events in the solar system. Both the
impacts of solwind and Shoemaker levy-9 support the argument that the impacts by comets may be a
regular feature and Earth is no exception to it. In the history of mankind, there is a strong possibility that
such events were observed by various civilizations.Early settlements of ancient India observed various
celestial objects like stars, constellations, planets and comets.Vedas like Rigveda, Atharvaveda refer
comets as “Dhumketu”. Certain hymns of Rig Vedastrongly support the possibility of impact event being
observed and recorded as eyewitness account. Reference of these celestial bodies is found in various
ancient legends of India. These legends may be work of imagination based on real observations. One
such legend is descent of Ganga from heaven. As per Valmiki Ramayana many aspects of this legend like
its composition, appearance, descent path and effects at the time of descent have close resemblance with
the impact event of a celestial body like comet. Ancient Stone carvings depicting the event provide major
clue about the celestial movement and the impact event.In this paper we have used ancient description
from Ramayana and Veda, and compared it with modern scientific facts and geological features of the
region described in the legend.There are Multiple water bodies and lakes in the Tibet behind mount
Kailash. This lake region is rich with finds like coesite, stishovite and other ultra high pressure finds that
are usually associated with the impact site. These lakes play crucial role in the water cycle of
Asia.Though there are lot of similarities in the legend and the available facts, as on date there is no
conclusive evidence which can prove the origin of river Gangaas a result of this event as mentioned in
thelegend. Thus this legend may be a result of observations mixed with belief.
Keywords: Comets, Ganga, Orion, Eridanus, mahabalipuram
1. Introduction
Impact event of solwind in 1979 and1994 shoemaker levy 9has drawn attention of the
scientific community on the possibility of similar event on Earth. Even the Tunguska event is
under discussion for possible comet impact. There are few sites like Egypt (Libyan Desert
Glass region) which are under discussion for similar impact events but till date there is no
conclusive evidence in the form of Cometary impact crater. Hence there is a strong possibility
that modern science is missing something while studying impacts by these low density
objects.One cannot ignore the possibility that such events were observed and may be recorded
by early human settlements.Certain hymns of Rig Veda indicate the possibility of such event
being observed by early Indian settlements. Thus there is no harm in considering their view
point, however the main challenge is the method followed by the ancient civilizations for the
recording and communicating these observations.In the ancient India one such event is
recorded in the form of story which talks about water coming to earth from outer space in the
form of river Ganga. For the purpose of this study we have referred the legend from Balkand
of Valmiki Ramayana
[1]
and its English translation by Ralph & Grifith
[2]
.
Rivers are the main source of drinking water so they are respected in every culture. Rivers like
Nile, Yangtze, Danube and other major rivers had a deep influence on the human civilization
but no river is considered as holy as Ganga. This respect for Ganga is not restricted to any
religion or region.