https://doi.org/10.3102/0091732X20907347
Review of Research in Education
March 2020, Vol. 44, pp. 332–369
DOI: 10.3102/0091732X20907347
Chapter reuse guidelines: sagepub.com/journals-permissions
© 2020 AERA. http://rre.aera.net
332
Chapter 12
Qualitative Comparative Analysis in Education
Research: Its Current Status and Future Potential
SEBNEM CILESIZ
University of Louisiana at Lafayette
THOMAS GRECKHAMER
Louisiana State University
Qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) is a set-theoretic configurational approach that
uses the logic of Boolean algebra to conceptualize and empirically examine potentially
complex causal relations. The potential of this methodological innovation to draw
innovative insights toward answering enduring questions and to foster novel research has
increasingly been realized in several social science disciplines. However, to date, limited
education research has taken advantage of this potential. The purpose of this review is to
facilitate an education research agenda that capitalizes on the strengths of QCA and its
set-theoretic approach. We introduce the foundations of QCA, outline the promise it holds
for education research, systematically review and appraise empirical education research
that has applied QCA, and complement this review with a review of research from outside
the field that may serve as inspiration for education researchers. In doing so, we highlight
areas of improved research designs in education research practice and point education
researchers to promising research directions. We conclude with suggestions for researchers
to weigh QCA’s strengths and limitations in comparison with other methods.
Q
ualitative comparative analysis (QCA), a set-theoretic configurational approach
based on Boolean algebra, was initially introduced more than 30 years ago and
has since been developed largely through the work of Charles Ragin (1987, 2000,
2008). QCA constitutes one of the few genuine methodological innovations in the
social sciences over the past decades (Gerring, 2001), and its potential has increasingly
been recognized and harnessed through empirical research in fields such as political
science, sociology, and management (Rihoux et al., 2013). QCA conceptualizes causal
907347RRE XX X 10.3102/0091732X20907347Review of Research in EducationCilesiz and Greckhamer: Qualitative Comparative Analysis in Education Research
research-article 2020