Stakeholder engagement in multi-objective optimization
of water quality monitoring network, case study: Karkheh
Dam reservoir
Mohammad Reza Nikoo, Shokoufeh Pourshahabi, Najmeh Rezazadeh
and M. Ehsan Shafiee
ABSTRACT
Reservoir water quality is important for water quality management downstream. A hierarchical
approach is developed to present the monitoring locations within a format that satisfies the
objectives of social stakeholders for making final decisions. First, a CE-QUAL-W2 model is applied to
simulate water quality variables in the reservoir for a long time using a set of historic data. Second,
transinformation entropy theory is used to quantify mutual information among a set of monitoring
stations for each water quality variable. Then, a non-dominating sorting genetic algorithm-based
model is developed for multi-objective optimization of the water quality monitoring network. Finally,
a social choice method is applied to the identified non-dominated solutions to achieve a strategy that
is compromised among stakeholders. The variations of the water quality variables at different depths
and different seasons are investigated. The proposed approach is illustrated for Karkheh Reservoir in
Iran. The number of optimized monitoring stations is the same for all seasons (three out of 22
potential stations) using different social choice methods. The results show the appropriate
performance of the proposed methodology for optimization of reservoir water quality monitoring
stations.
Mohammad Reza Nikoo (corresponding author)
Shokoufeh Pourshahabi
Department of Civil and Environmental
Engineering,
Shiraz University,
Shiraz,
Iran
E-mail: nikoo@shirazu.ac.ir
Najmeh Rezazadeh
Civil Engineering Faculty,
Ferdowsi University,
Mashhad,
Iran
M. Ehsan Shafiee
Sensus,
Morrisville, NC 27650,
USA
Key words | CE-QUAL-W2 model, NSGA-II multi-objective optimization method, reservoir monitoring
network, social choice, transinformation entropy
INTRODUCTION
Sampling locations are designed to monitor reservoir water
quality. The design of sampling locations is difficult due to a
wide range of water quality variables that can be used to pre-
sent water quality, the temporal and spatial characteristics
of sampling, and the duration and objectives of sampling
(Harmancioglu et al. ). For optimization of a water qual-
ity monitoring program, various regulations and the physical
and geographical properties of reservoirs must be con-
sidered in formulating this non-linear, complex problem
(Behmel et al. ).
The study of the placement of monitoring stations in a
reservoir is limited in the literature, although similar studies
can be found for identifying locations to monitor water qual-
ity in river and groundwater resources. Lee & Kwon ()
and Lee et al. () proposed methodologies using statistical
analysis to reduce redundant sampling locations in a reser-
voir. Based on information theory, Lee et al. ()
proposed an approach for optimization of water quality
monitoring stations in a reservoir. They used water quality
data at similar depths of Lake Yongdam. Instead of using
an optimization approach, they tested all possible combi-
nations to find the optimal solution among potential
combinations of stations. These studies are not suitable for
the large reservoirs, at which the potential sampling
966 © IWA Publishing 2017 Water Science & Technology: Water Supply | 17.4 | 2017
doi: 10.2166/ws.2016.196
Downloaded from https://iwaponline.com/ws/article-pdf/17/4/966/409004/ws017040966.pdf
by guest
on 16 June 2020