International Women Online Journal of Distance Education
(April, 2022 Volume: 11 Issue: 1 Article: 02 ISSN: 2147-0367
8
Copyright © International Women Online Journal of Distance Education / www.wojde.org
MITIGATING THE MATILDA EFFECT ON CHRISTINE VON
PRÜMMER: A (RE-)ILLUMINATION OF HER EXTRAORDINARY
WORK
Hilary SCHMIDT
hschmidt1@athabasca.edu
Athabasca University, Canada
Susan BAINBRIDGE
susanbainbridge@athabascau.ca
Athabasca University, Canada
Norine WARK
norinewark@gmail.com
Education, Technology, & Research Consultant, Canada
Received: 31.01.2022 Accepted: 26.03.2022
ABSTRACT
The Matilda effect refers to the systematic under-recognition of women’s accomplishments
in scientific fields (Rossiter, 1993), which we previously proposed extends into additional
fields coded male within our culture, such as educational technology and distance
education (Schmidt et al., 2021). In the current paper, we attempt to reverse the Matilda
effect by highlighting the accomplishments of a groundbreaking early feminist distance
education researcher, Christine von Prümmer, whose cross-national, multi-institutional
empirical research focused on gender differences in online, digital, and distance education
(ODDE). We briefly review von Prümmer’s biographical background before exploring her
major achievements in ODDE research, which include challenging accepted notions
regarding the supposed gender neutrality of theories of learning (such as andragogy),
uncovering empirical evidence of female distance learners’ needs as distinct from those of
“standard” (i.e., male) distance learners, and offering guidance to institutions across the
world regarding how they might best support women learners’ success in an ODDE
environment. We conclude that von Prümmer’s omission from standard textbooks and
other works focused on distance education provides further evidence of the Matilda effect
within this field.
Keywords: Matilda effect, women researchers, distance education, online education,
gender differences, gender equity, feminist researchers
INTRODUCTION
In an earlier paper, we argued that the Matilda effect—the well-established phenomenon
by which women’s scientific accomplishments are systematically under-recognized—
extends into the field of open, digital, and distance education (ODDE; Rossiter, 1993;
Schmidt et al., 2021). Given the association of ODDE with computing and digital
technology, both of which remain largely coded male within our culture (Makarova et al.,
2019), we suggested that this extension was likely (Schmidt et al., 2021). As an example
of the Matilda effect’s impact within ODDE, we described the accomplishments of Starr
Roxanne Hiltz, a superlative early online learning researcher, whose work is now largely
forgotten.