Analysis of the Development of Allodynia: Correlation Between Migraine Duration and Severity
B. Lu, X. Li, S. Zhao, E. Connors, S. Kori
MAP Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Mountain View, CA
CONCLUSIONS
• In this study, the presence of allodynia at time of treatment was
associated with the severity of migraine.
• No correlation between the duration of migraine and the presence of
allodynia was observed.
• This retrospective analysis suggests that migraine severity is a
signifcant factor in determining whether a subject will experience
central sensitization as measured by allodynia.
RESULTS METHODS RESULTS
REFERENCES
1. Dodick D; Silberstein S. Central Sensitization theory of migraine: Clinical
implications. Headache. 2006;S182-S191.
2. Burstein R; Collins B; Jakubowski M. Defeating migraine pain with triptans:
a race against the development of cutaneous allodynia. Ann. Neurol.
2004;55:19-26.
3. Bigal ME; Ashina S; Burstein R; et al. Prevalence and characteristics of
allodynia in headache sufferers. Neurology. 2008;70:1525-1533.
4. Burstein R; Cutrer MF; Yarnitsky D. The development of cutaneous allodynia
during a migraine attack clinical evidence for the sequential recruitment
of spinal and supraspinal nociceptive neurons in migraine. Brain.
2000;123:1703-1709.
5. Christoph-Diener H; Ferrari M; Mansbach H. Predicting the Response to
Sumatriptan. Neurology. 2004;63:520-524.
ADDITIONAL REFERENCE
Tepper S; Kori S; Borland S; et al. Effcacy and Safety of MAP0004, Orally
Inhaled DHE in Treating Migraines With and Without Allodynia.Headache.
2011;1-11.
BACKGROUND
Presented at the 54th Annual International Meeting
of the American Headache Society
Los Angeles, CA, USA
June 21-24, 2012
FIGURE 3. Percentage of Subjects with Presence of Allodynia as a
Function of Pain Level at the Time of Treatment (n=771)
TABLE 1. Allodynia Presentation at the Time of Treatment Across All
Baseline Characteristics and Demographics
Study funded by MAP Pharmaceuticals, Inc. ©2012. All rights reserved.
• Cutaneous allodynia is defned as the perception of pain from
non-nociceptive stimuli applied to normal skin and is believed
to be a clinical presentation of central sensitization.
1
• Central sensitization is a theory of migraine pathophysiology
that describes abnormal neuronal excitability in the brainstem,
specifcally the trigeminal nucleus caudalis.
1
• The presence of allodynia is a marker for resistant migraine.
2
Furthermore, the probability of a consistent, pain-free outcome
when a migraine is treated with triptans has been shown to be
reduced if the subject has developed allodynia.
2
• It has been reported that up to 70% of migraineurs experience
allodynia sometime during the attack.
3
However, factors leading
to the development of allodynia are not well understood.
• The hypothesis that allodynia is time-dependent suggests
a process where the peripheral nociceptors that innervate
intracranial blood vessels and meninges become sensitized,
followed by sensitization of second- and third-order
trigeminovascular neurons.
4
This hypothesis implies that
patients should take medication at the onset of a migraine
attack.
4
• Pain severity at the time of treatment has been shown to be
the most important predicting factor for the response to acute
treatment of migraine
5
and may be related to the development
of allodynia.
To evaluate the relationship between allodynia and the duration
and severity of migraine.
OBJECTIVE
This retrospective analysis included 792 subjects in the double-
blind period of a Phase 3, placebo-controlled, randomized
clinical trial of an investigational acute treatment for migraine
(MAP0004). Duration of migraine (time from onset of migraine to
the time of treatment as defned by the subject) and information
on pain level at the time of treatment (scale of mild, moderate
or severe) were recorded by subjects using an electronic diary.
In addition, allodynia information was obtained at the time of
treatment using a standard questionnaire (Figure 1) captured in
real time by the electronic diary.
This was a single migraine attack study and therefore frequency
of migraines was not a factor that was evaluated as contributing
to the presence of allodynia.
Correlations between the percentage of subjects who experienced
allodynia, the severity of migraine and the duration of migraine
were analyzed by Fisher’s exact test and chi-square test where
indicated.
FIGURE 2. Percentage of Subjects with Presence of Allodynia at the Time
of Treatment as a Function of Duration of Migraine
57%
51%
48%
56%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
≤ 1 hr >1-4 hr >4-8 hr >8 hr
Allodynia Presence at
the Time of Treatment
Duration of Migraine
n=132/230 n=162/321 n=58/122 n=55/198
56%
45%
43%
46%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
≤1 hr >1-4 hr >4-8 hr >8 hr
Duration of Migraine
Allodynia Presence at
the Time of Treatment
n=74/132 n=77/172 n=28/65 n=21/46
59%
57%
53%
65%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
≤1 hr >1-4 hr >4-8 hr >8 hr
Duration of Migraine
Allodynia Presence at
the Time of Treatment
n=58/98 n=85/149 n=30/57 n=34/52
The presence of allodynia at the time of treatment did not differ in relation
to the duration of the migraine (chi-square p= 0.2182), regardless of
migraine severity (moderate pain, chi-square p= 0.1807; severe pain,
chi-square p= 0.5830).
48.2%
58.1%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
MODERATE SEVERE
Pain Symptom Score at Time of Treatment
Allodynia Presence at
the Time of Treatment
*p=
0.0053
*
n=200/415 n=207/356
Subjects reporting severe migraine pain experienced signifcantly more
allodynia (58.4%) than subjects with moderate pain (48.2%; Fisher’s
exact p= 0.0053).
A. All Subjects (n=771*)
B. Subjects with Moderate Pain at the Time of Treatment (n=415)
DEMOGRAPHICS YES NO
Total mITT 419 (52.9%) 373 (47.1%)
Gender
Female 390 (53.8%) 335 (46.2%)
Male 29 (43.3%) 38 (56.7%)
Age
≤40 years 190 (48.6%) 201 (51.4%)
>40 years 229 (57.1%) 172 (42.9%)
Race
Caucasian 354 (51.8%) 329 (48.2%)
Non-Caucasian 65 (59.6%) 44 (40.4%)
Years Since First Headache
Median 20 16
Min, Max 2, 54 2, 56
Years Since Migraine Diagnosis
Median 13 11
Min, Max 1, 50 1, 54
Overall HIT-6 Score
Median 66 65
Min, Max 53,78 48,78
The presence of allodynia at the time of treatment was defined as answering
“Yes” to at least two of the following questions:
1. Is your scalp tender to touch?
2. Does combing your hair bother you?
3. Does wearing your glasses or sunglasses bother you?
4. Does washing your face bother you?
5. Are your teeth and gums tender to touch?
6. Is your skin over the face tender to touch?
FIGURE 1. Allodynia Questionnaire
53% of subjects reported experiencing allodynia at the time of treatment.
C. Subjects with Severe Pain at the Time of Treatment (n=356)
METHODS
RESULTS
* Subjects that did not report time of treatment information were not included in the analysis