SOCIAL FACTORS IN USER PERCEPTIONS AND RESPONSES TO
ADVERTISING IN ONLINE SOCIAL NETWORKING COMMUNITIES
Fue Zeng, Li Huang, Wenyu Dou
ABSTRACT: With the advent of popular Web destinations such as MySpace and Facebook, online social networking
communities now occupy the center stage of e-commerce. Yet these online social networking communities must balance the
trade-off between advertising revenue and user experience. Drawing on the sociology and advertising literature, this study
investigates the impacts of social identity and group norms on community users' group intentions to accept advertising in online
social networking communities. By outlining how this type of group intention could influence community members' perceptions
and value judgments of such advertising, this study delineates possible mechanisms by which community members may respond
positively to community advertising. The authors test the proposed theoretical framework on a sample of 327 popular online
community users in China and obtain general support. Implications for the prospect of advertising in online social networking
communities are discussed.
Keywords: Online social networking communities, advertising responses, social factors.
With the advent of popular Web destinations such as MySpace
and Facebook, a new kind of online community now occupy
the center stage in e-commerce, namely, social networking
communities (Bausch and Han 2006). eMarketer (2009)
projects that advertising revenue from social network
communities in the United States will reach more than 17.9
million, or 15% of total U.S. online advertising revenues, by
2013. The popularity of online networking communities also
has been growing in other parts of the world. More than 200
million users per month visit QQ-Zone, the Chinese online
social networking community, which is considered the largest
social network site in the world (McLeod 2006). Leveraging
this huge base of community users, QQ.com earned US$120.9
million in online advertising revenue in 2008 (Tecent 2008).
The rapid growth of online social networking communities
has caught the attention of advertisers that hope to find new
ways to harness these communities for their advertising
purposes (Hart 2007). However, as the communities battle to
garner long-term, sustainable advertising revenues, they
encounter the severe risk that members will feel exploited if
the sites suddenly appear overrun with ads (Mesure and
Griggs 2007). The burgeoning industry thus has been under
increasing public pressure to strike a balance between the need
to generate advertising revenue and members' demand for
uninterrupted social experiences (Nutley 2007). A 2008 report
by IDC found that 43% of social network users never clicked
on ads, a dramatic difference from the 80% of other Internet
users who did so at least once a year. Furthermore, 23% of
nonusers of online communities who clicked on an ad then
made a purchase, whereas only 11% of social network users
who clicked on ads did the same (eMarketer 2009).
Little academic research addresses the concerns held by
community organizers about how to convince users to be
more receptive to advertising in online social communities. In
particular, though various e-commerce studies investigate
online communities (e.g., Bagozzi and Dholakia 2002; DeKay
2009; Gangadharbatla 2008), none has explored members'
perceptions or acceptance of advertising in social network
communities. To gain insights into this important area of
research and application, we draw on sociology and
advertising literature to examine how social identity and group
norms of online community members may influence
perceptions of and behavioral responses to advertising.
This study therefore makes several theoretical contributions.
First, an emerging stream of e-commerce literature uses
sociological perspectives to examine how social factors may
influence community members' participation in communities;
we extend this line of inquiry by exploring a different set of
outcome measures, namely, how community members
perceive and react to advertising in community sites. Second,
we bridge the link between sociological factors in online
communities and advertising responses by including group
intentions (Bagozzi and Dholakia 2002) and establishing that
group intentions to accept advertising in online communities
shapes community members' perceptions of that advertising.
This application of the group intention perspective is novel in
this context and identifies a route by which community
members may demonstrate receptiveness to advertising in
Journal of Interactive Advertising, Vol 10 No 1 (Fall 2009), pp. 1 13.
© 2010 American Academy of Advertising, All rights reserved
ISSN 1525 2019