Comparing Reasons, Practices and
Effects of ISO 9000 Certification and
TQM Implementation in Norwegian
SMEs and Large Firms
HONGYI SUN AND TSZ-KIT CHENG
City University of H ong Kong
This article records the empirical research that investigates the reasons
behind, practices and effects of ISO 9000 certification and Total Q uality
Management (TQ M) implementation in small and medium-sized (SME) and
large manufacturing companies. The research is based on a sur vey of 180
N orwegian manufacturing companies. The main findings are (1) the SMEs
implement ISO 9000 standards and TQ M mainly because of market and
customer demand or external pressure rather than internal initiation;(2) in
practicing TQ M, the SMEs focus on informal, people-oriented approaches;
large firms are relatively more structured, organized and process-oriented;(3)
different facets of TQ M contribute differently in SMEs and large firms; (4) no
significant relation exists between the current ISO 9000 certification and TQ M
practices/improvement of business performance. The conclusion is that there
are some significant differences between SMEs and large firms in implanting
ISO 9000 certification and TQ M. These differences trigger discussions on
practical implications for managers in SMEs and large firms. Finally, the
limitations of the research and implications for future research are explored.
K EY W O R D S: comparative study;ISO 9000 certification;TQ M;SME
Introduction
The contribution of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) has been recog-
nized worldwide. For example, in the UK, about two-thirds of the workforce is
in this sector and virtually all large companies depend on SMEs for their
suppliers and subcontractors (Parkin and Parkin, 1996). These small businesses
generate over a third of UK business turnover (North et al., 1998). In the USA,
small firms employ 65% of all US manufacturing workers. As large manu-
facturers increase their dependence on suppliers for parts and services, the
performance and capabilities of small manufacturers become even more critical
to the entire manufacturing sector and to the health of the US economy. The year
1999 was declared the Year of Small Manufacturers in the USA. In Finland,
421
International Small Business Journal
Copyright © 2002
SAGE Publications (London,
Thousand O aks and N ew D elhi)
[0266–2426 (200211)20:4; 421–442; 029142]
Vol 20(4):421–442
is
b
j