INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON COMMUNICATION, COMPUTER AND POWER (ICCCP'09) MUSCAT, FEBRUARY 15-18, 2009
© SQU-2009 ISSN: 1813-419X
Optimum Allocation of Wind Based DG in
Unbalanced Rural Network
Y. M. Attwa
1
, E.F. El-Saadany
1
, and M. H. Albadi
1
Abstract— Recent development in small renewable/clean
generation technologies, such as wind turbines,
photovoltaic, fuel cells, and microturbines, has drawn
distribution utilities’ attention to the possible change in the
distribution system infrastructure and policy by deploying
Distributed Generation (DG). In this paper an Optimal
Power Flow (OPF) algorithm is used to determine the
optimum allocation of wind-based DG in order to
minimizing the total power losses. The OPF is formulated
as a Mixed Integer Non-Linear Programming (MINLP)
problem, with an objective function to minimize the system
power losses. The constraints include voltage limits at
different buses (slack, generation, and load buses) of the
system, feeder capacity, and maximum penetration limit of
DG units. Moreover, the capacity factor of wind based DG
is calculated using the Rayleigh model of wind speed,
represented by the mean wind speed at the potential
locations, and wind turbines data. The OPF model is
applied to a typical unbalanced system with different
scenarios including restrictions on the size and location of
DG. The results show that there are different optimum
allocations of the DG units based on the constraints of each
scenario penetration level. In addition, the results
demonstrate that increasing penetration level of DG over a
certain threshold can cause negative impacts on the system
power losses.
Key words—Distributed generation, optimal power flow,
unbalanced system, wind energy.
I. INTRODUCTION
Under the new deregulation policy and with the expected
proliferation of DG technologies, a reasonable share of
electricity is expected to be supplied by different DG systems.
Further, introducing more DG units into the distribution
system will not only help in meeting the electricity demand,
relief transmission congestion, but will also introduce variety
of other benefits. A study by the Electric Power Research
Institute (EPRI) indicates that by 2010, 25% of the new
generation will be distributed; while, a study by the Natural
Gas Foundation concluded that this figure could be as high as
30% [1]. The European Renewable Energy Study (TERES),
commissioned by the European Union (EU) to examine the
feasibility of EU CO2-reduction goals and the EU renewable
energy targets, found that around 60% of the renewable
1
The authors are with the Department of Electrical and Computer
Engineering at the University of Waterloo, Ontario, Canada (e-mail:
ymoustaf@uwaterloo.ca).
energy potential that can be utilized until 2010 can be
categorized as decentralized power sources [2].
Optimal operation and planning analysis is often performed
via optimization studies. Traditionally, these optimizations are
performed based on minimizing the operational cost while
maintaining an appropriate security margin. With the
introduction of distributed generation in distribution systems,
some aspects of the system optimization related to both
planning and operation will arise. Some of these aspects are
the penetration level and the optimum location of DG that will
reduce electrical losses in the distribution system, which, in
turns, will reduce the operation cost. Several articles that
address the use of artificial intelligence algorithms to optimize
DG placement, based on minimizing power losses, have been
published [1]–[6]. Reference [1] solves the problem by an
exhaustive algorithm, [2] employs the Tabu search method, [3]
uses a fuzzy genetic algorithm and analytical approaches are
presented in [4]. Other papers considered the cost of power
interruptions [5] and minimizing peaks [6]. The objectives of
[7] include reduction in T&D losses and improvement of
voltage profile of the system, with due consideration of fixed
and variable costs. In [8] an optimization model for
minimization of losses through constrained power flows and
optimal sitting of DG units in a multi-bus distribution network
is presented. The main objective is to minimize the line losses
subject to meeting generation and transmission constraints and
consumer demand. Most of the previous work done for
allocating DG in the distribution system assumed that the
system is perfectly balanced and the DG sources are fully
guaranteed; two assumptions that are totally invalid for
practical distribution systems as well as renewable DG. This
paper will introduce the DG optimum size and location
optimization problem taking into consideration two vital
issues: the impact of system unbalance and the uncertainty of
non conventional types of DG.
In this paper a novel OPF based technique is used to
determine the optimum allocation of wind based DG in the
distribution system. The problem is formulated as a MINLP,
taking into consideration the effect of system unbalance, and
the uncertainty of the wind based DG. The technique is
applied on a typical unbalanced rural distribution system, with
different scenarios. Moreover, a sensitivity analysis is
conducted in order to determine the impact of increasing the
DG penetration level on system losses.
The paper is organized as follows: the next section broadly
discusses the main objective of this work and the proposed
procedure to accomplish it. Calculation of the capacity factor
of wind based DG is explained in section III. Further, section
VI presents a practical distribution system case study with the
325