Abstract — There have been a number of methods proposed
for accurate state of charge (SOC) estimation of a battery as an
important role of the battery management System (BMS).
However, adequate test data of batteries and BMS development
costs must be taken into consideration before application in
actual vehicles. In addition, different algorithms need to be
adopted according to the type of energy storage device and
system configuration. For a mild-HEV hybrid energy storage
device that uses the ultracapacitor module and the VRLA battery,
the small capacitance of ultracapacitor module makes accurate
SOC difficult. Accordingly, this paper introduces a dynamic SOC
estimation algorithm capable of SOC compensation of the
ultracapacitor module even when there is current input and
output. A cycle profile that simulates the operating conditions of
a mild-HEV was applied to a vehicle simulator to verify the
effectiveness of the proposed algorithm based on testing.
I. INTRODUCTION
Energy storage devices for Hybrid Electric Vehicles
(HEVs) are required to have excellent power density and
energy efficiency characteristics and guarantee long life cycle
and usage even under frequent high-current charging and
discharging conditions. According to these needs, energy
storage devices with high power and longevity, such as Ni-
MH or Li-Ion, have been proposed and used. In the case of
mild-HEVs that only use limited functions of HEVs including
idle-stop/start or regenerative braking, there have been a
number of studies on using Value-Regulated Lead-Acid
(VRLA) batteries that yield relatively high price-performance
ratios.
However, using a VRLA battery as a stand-alone energy
storage device for a mild-HEV has disadvantages in terms of
lifetime, power characteristics and weight, calling for
improvements in the performance of the VRLA battery, which
has its limitations. In turn, recent studies have suggested
combining the VRLA battery with the ultracapacitor module
capable of high efficiency and high-current charging and
discharging to implement an energy storage device with
improved efficiency and prolonged lifetime. [1][2][3]
In order to effectively use the VRLA battery and the
ultracapacitor module as a hybrid energy storage device,
accurate State of Charge (SOC) estimation must be performed
by the Battery Management System (BMS) that manages and
monitors the energy storage device. SOC estimation is one of
the most important issues for application products that use
energy storage devices. Known methods for SOC estimation
include using chemical reaction, voltage, current integration
and internal impedance. [4]
The chemical method involves estimating SOC by
numerically representing the linear reduction of electrolyte’s
specific gravity (SG) during battery discharging. SG is the
ratio of the weight of a solution to the weight of an equal
volume of water at a specified temperature. However, the
chemical method can only be used when electrolyte can be
directly accessed, such as in the case of lead-acid batteries.
Another drawback of the chemical method is that it can yield
different results according to the ambient temperature and the
amount of electrolyte.
The voltage method uses the correlation between SOC and
the battery voltage during charging and discharging. Although
this method provides accurate SOC based on Open Circuit
Voltage (OCV) after a sufficient time for stabilization,
different results are produced depending on the ambient
temperature, discharging rate (C-rate), usage time, and
variation in the characteristics of battery’s internal resistance.
Also referred to as “Coulomb counting” or “Ampere-hour
counting”, the current method calculates SOC by integrating
battery’s input and output current. However, this method
requires that an accurate account of initial capacity and current
leakage and the sensing error are accumulated over time,
gradually increasing the SOC error.
The internal impedance method estimates SOC by
measuring the variation in internal impedance according to
battery’s charging and discharging. Drawbacks of the internal
impedance method are that it is difficult to measure battery’s
impedance while the cell is reacting and that impedance is
sensitive to temperature.
Since precise SOC estimation is difficult with
aforementioned methods, new approaches such as Fuzzy logic,
Kalman filtering and Neural network, are being proposed, but
they call for accuracy in battery modeling and there are
drawbacks such as significant amounts of test data and
increased costs associated with using 32-bit MCUs for fast
numerical processing. Therefore, accurate SOC estimation
requires research efforts that utilize advantages of each
method and do not use relatively large amounts of test data
while taking into consideration the cost perspective.
In a hybrid energy storage device, the ultracapacitor
module is used as the main power source due to its
A Study on the dynamic SOC compensation of an
Ultracapacitor module for the Hybrid Energy
Storage System
Hyun-Sik Song
1
, Jin-Beom Jung
2
, Baek-Haeng-Lee
2
, Dong-Hyun Shin
2
,
Byoung-Hoon Kim
2
, Yu-Cheol Park
2
, Hoon-Heo
1
, Hee-Jun Kim
3
1
Dept. of Control and Instrumentation Eng., Korea University, Korea
2
Electronic System R&D Center, Korea Automotive Technology Institute, Korea
3
Dept. of Electrical Eng., Hanyang University, Korea, E-mail: hjkim@hanyang.ac.kr
1-4244-2491-7/09/$20.00 ©2009 IEEE