International Journal of Civil & Environmental Engineering IJCEE-IJENS Vol: 17 No: 05 10
172705-8484-IJCEE-IJENS © October 2017 IJENS
I J E N S
Analysis of Relation Between Safety Cost and OHS
Performance in Building Construction to Improve
Safety Performance
Yusuf Latief, Rossy Armyn Machfudiyanto, Arina Devi
Department of Civil Engineering, Universitas Indonesia, Kampus UI Depok, Jawa Barat, Indonesia
Email: rossyarmyn@gmail.com
Abstract— Number of accidents in construction sector in
Indonesia is high, including building construction. The high
number of accidents indicates that a good system of safety and
health management is required. The purpose of this study is
knowing the relationship of safety cost and OHS performance in
building construction in Jabodetabek with statistical methods.
The result shows that safety cost’ components which have the
most influence to control OHS’ risks are rotary lamp, life line,
and tools license permit. Moreover, safety cost’ components that
influence accidents the most are evacuation route, BPJS, safety
vest, and worker’s identity cards.
Index Term-- Safety Cost, Safety Performance, OHS Risk
Control, Accidents
I. INTRODUCTION
Occupational Safety and Health (K3) is a very important
aspect, especially in the construction sector. In its work, the
construction sector involves jobs with substantial risk of harm.
K3 management system in Indonesia can be said still not well
implemented, indicated from the high number of work
accidents that occurred in Indonesia. Based on data of accident
cases from PT. Social Security of Workers (Jamsostek), there
were 95,624 cases in 2006, 83,714 cases in 2007, 94,736 cases
in 2008, 96,314 cases in 2009, 98,711 cases in 2010, and
99,491 cases in 2011. Of 31.9 % of the cases are from the
construction sector. These figures support the argument of
high occupational accident risk in the construction sector,
including building construction.
Construction organizers tend to underestimate the OSH
management system as it is considered to only add to the cost
budget in construction works. Safety and Health Expenditures
for construction sector are regulated in Circular Letter no. 66 /
SE / M / 2015 on the Cost of Operation Management System
Occupational Safety and Health (SMK3) Construction of
Public Works. However, because it is considered as a burden,
construction operators tend to ignore the implementation of
SMK3.
In a study of 25 building projects undertaken by Gurcanli et al.
(2015), some construction service firms actually allocate
lower K3 costs along with increased project size and height. In
fact, the cost of K3 does not reach 5% of the total cost, ie the
research is 2.6% of the total cost. Based on research conducted
by Muhammad, et. al. (2015), explained that according to
Smallwood, J. (2004), the estimated cost allocation for OHS
management implementation in construction companies is
0.5% to 3% of the total project cost, and work accident costs
exceed 5% of the total project cost.
Based on some existing research, the cost of running SMK3 in
building construction projects is often allocated very small to
reduce total cost burden. Construction companies usually
consider allocating funds for OSH management for
construction projects, including building construction projects,
as one indicator that could harm the company. This is
unfortunate, because the high number of occupational
accidents in the construction sector needs to be overcome by
the improvement of OHS performance.
The purpose of this study are:
1. Identify the cost component of the implementation of
SMK3 allocated to the building construction project.
2. Identify the components of the cost of implementing SMK3
in building construction projects to improve OSH
performance.
3. Identify the cost component of the implementation of
SMK3 which is a priority to improve K3 performance.
4. Analysis the effect of SMK3 implementation cost on the
performance of K3 in building construction project.
II. THEORITICAL REVIEW
OHS performance, by definition from OHSAS 18001: 2007, is
a measurable outcome of the management of OSH risks in an
organization. Measurements of OHS performance include
measuring the effectiveness of control carried out by the
organization. OHS performance can also be measured by
comparing against OSH policy, OHS objectives, and other
OHS performance requirements.
The organization shall establish, implement and maintain
procedures to monitor and measure the OHS performance on a
regular basis. Such procedures are important for qualitative
and quantitative measurement according to the needs of the
organization; monitor extensions that enable the organization's
OH & E objectives to be achieved; monitor the effectiveness
of controls for health and safety, proactively measure