727
© The Author(s) 2020. Published by Oxford University Press. All rights reserved.
For permissions, please e-mail: journals.permissions@oup.com.
Letters to the Editor
Why discuss dementia risk reduction with
middle-aged patients in general practice?
Kali Godbee*
,
Department of General Practice, The University of Melbourne, Melbourne, VIC, Australia.
*Correspondence to Kali Godbee, Department of General Practice, The University of Melbourne, 780 Elizabeth Street,
Parkville, Melbourne, VIC 3010, Australia; E-mail: kali.godbee@unimelb.edu.au
Dementia is a complex condition mainly affecting older people
(1). Fewer than half of cases are thought to be attributable to
modifable risk factors (2, 3), and the quality of evidence for de-
mentia risk reduction is moderate at best (4). There is stigma,
fear and lack of understanding among the patient population
(5). The question for general practitioners and general practice
nurses (GPNs) is, why mention dementia at all? Why not simply
manage risk of cardiovascular disease and diabetes, and (given
the overlapping risk factors) hope that reduces risk of dementia
as well (4)? Here are fve reasons for general practitioners and
GPNs to explicitly discuss dementia risk reduction with their
middle-aged patients at elevated risk of developing dementia as
they get older.
1. Professional standards and responsibilities
The Regulation of General Practice Programme Board in England
(6) and the Royal Australian College of General Practice in
Australia (7) require general practices to provide health promo-
tion and preventive services that are based on patient need and
best available evidence. Patient need for dementia risk reduction
is manifest: dementia risk factors are prevalent in middle-aged
patients in England (8) and Australia (9, 10), yet patient under-
standing of dementia risk reduction is poor (11, 12). In terms of
best available evidence, new (4, 13) and existing (14, 15) guidelines
indicate that physical activity, tobacco cessation and safe alcohol
consumption should be recommended to middle-aged patients to
reduce dementia risk. A Mediterranean-like diet and management
of weight, hypertension, diabetes and dyslipidaemia may also be
recommended (4, 13–15). Discussing dementia risk reduction is a
crucial component of adhering to professional standards of general
practice.
Beyond professional standards, general practitioners and GPNs
have a professional responsibility to ensure patients are fully in-
formed about all aspects of their health care (16, 17) and are
supported to understand the consequences of care and treatment op-
tions (18). Patients have a right to know that their risk of dementia
is increased if, for example, they continue smoking or discontinue
prescribed statins.
2. Patients want to know about dementia risk
reduction from a trusted source
Nearly 80% of people surveyed in general practitioner waiting
rooms in England and Australia wanted to learn more about re-
ducing dementia (19), and the dementia awareness component of
the National Health Service (NHS) health checks was welcomed
by patients in England (20). Furthermore, we know that dementia
is ‘over-expressed’ in the media, with many messages overstating
the evidence (21). General practitioners and GPNs who discuss
dementia risk reduction can clarify points of confusion for their
middle-aged patients and appropriately tailor advice and support.
3. Discussing dementia risk reduction could
strengthen working alliances
Relational aspects of primary care are important. The working al-
liance between patient and clinician comprises the bond between
the two parties, collaborative goal setting and agreement on the
required tasks to reach the goals (22). Discussing dementia risk
reduction can reinforce to the patient that their clinical care team
genuinely cares about them and their long-term health goals and
provide an opportunity to revisit goals and agreed tasks. General
practitioners and GPNs might be concerned about causing distress
or unnecessary worry (20), but there is limited evidence to suggest
this. In one evaluation in England, only 9% of 164 participants
who recalled the dementia awareness component of the NHS
Health Check felt uncomfortable when dementia risk reduction
was mentioned (20). Done skilfully and sensitively, a discussion
about dementia risk reduction may actually strengthen working
alliances with patients.
4. Discussing dementia risk reduction could
motivate patients to change their behaviour
Dementia is one of the most feared health conditions (5, 12). It is
the leading cause of death in England (23) and the second leading
cause of death in Australia (24). Whereas repetitive messages about
Family Practice, 2020, 727–729
doi:10.1093/fampra/cmaa032
Advance Access publication 7 April 2020
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/fampra/article/37/5/727/5816758 by guest on 13 April 2022