Hydrothermal Stability of Fe-BEA as an NH
3
‑SCR Catalyst
Soran Shwan,*
,†
Radka Nedyalkova,
†
Jonas Jansson,
‡
John Korsgren,
‡
Louise Olsson,
†
and Magnus Skoglundh
†
†
Competence Centre for Catalysis, Chalmers University of Technology, SE-41296, Gothenburg, Sweden
‡
Volvo Group Trucks Technology, SE-40508, Gothenburg, Sweden
ABSTRACT: The hydrothermal stability of Fe-BEA as a selective catalytic reduction (SCR) catalyst was experimentally
studied. Cordierite supported Fe-BEA samples were hydrothermally treated at 600 and 700 °C for 3-100 h to capture the effect
of aging time and temperature. Before and after aging the samples were characterized with BET, XPS, XRD, and NH
3
-TPD. The
catalytic performance of the samples with respect to NO oxidation, NH
3
oxidation, and NO reduction (NH
3
-SCR) was studied
by flow reactor experiments to correlate changes of the catalytic performance with structural changes of the zeolite and the iron
phases. The NH
3
-SCR experiments did not show any significant decrease in activity after a short time of aging (3 h at 700 °C)
even though the ammonia storage capacity decreased by 40% and the oxidation state of iron slightly increased. A longer time of
aging resulted in decreased activity for NO reduction during low temperatures (150-300 °C), while at higher temperatures
(400-500 °C) the activity remained high. The results indicate that the NO reduction is more sensitive at low temperatures to
changes in the oxidation state of iron caused by hydrothermal aging than at higher temperatures. Furthermore, a maximum in
activity for NO oxidation and increased oxidation state of iron (Fe
3+
) indicate Fe
2
O
3
particle growth.
1. INTRODUCTION
Catalyst deactivation is a significant and inevitable problem in
many important applications. The deactivation causes negative
economic as well as environmental effects, and there is
considerable motivation for understanding the mechanisms
for catalyst decay to design stable catalysts and catalytic
processes. Selective catalytic reduction with ammonia (NH
3
-
SCR) is a well-established and effective method to eliminate
nitrogen oxides (NO
X
) under oxygen excess for stationary and,
more recently, mobile applications.
1
Vanadia-based catalysts
were initially used for SCR applications. However, problems
including decrease in activity and selectivity, and also the
toxicity of vanadia, which may form volatile compounds at high
temperatures, have promoted the development of alternatives
to vanadia-based catalysts, especially for mobile applications.
1
Metal-ion-exchanged zeolites, particularly based on copper
2-7
or iron,
1,3,8-11
have in this connection proven to be very active
and promising alternatives to vanadia in SCR catalysts.
1,12,13
Iron-based zeolites are generally more active for SCR at higher
temperatures compared to zeolites based on copper, which
have good low-temperature performance but lower high-
temperature activity. Furthermore, Kamasamudram et al. have
compared iron- and copper-based zeolites and shown higher
SCR performance for zeolites based on iron under transient
conditions.
14
Recently, promising results have been shown for
simultaneously exchanged Fe/Cu zeolites combining the
advantages of both metals in the same catalyst.
15
Several challenges arise when using these materials in exhaust
after-treatment systems for lean burn or diesel vehicles. One
problem is catalyst deactivation by poisoning caused by
hydrocarbons,
16-18
especially during cold start conditions.
The resistance of metal-exchanged zeolites toward hydrocarbon
poisoning can be enhanced by the addition of a protection layer
of mordenite.
16
Another problem is thermal deactivation due to
the high-temperature conditions in connection with the
regeneration of the particulate filter, which usually is placed
close to the SCR catalyst. The regeneration occurs typically
between 600 and 700 °C.
19
Hence, the hydrothermal stability
of metal-based zeolites is crucial.
Previous studies of Fe-ZSM-5 as an SCR catalyst have
shown stable catalytic properties below 500 °C under
hydrothermal conditions. However, at higher temperatures
deactivation becomes a problem.
1,10,20,21
Different mechanisms
have been proposed for the deactivation caused by hydro-
thermal treatment. The two major mechanisms are (i) the loss
of catalytic surface area due to pore collapse of crystallites of
the active phase and (ii) the loss of support area due to support
collapse and crystallite growth.
22
At temperatures above 500 °C
Brønsted acidity has been shown to decrease due to
dealumination.
1,3,23-26
Water also favors migration of iron in
Fe-exchanged zeolites which results in formation of metal oxide
clusters and particles with reduced activity.
27
Brandenberger et
al. proposed a mechanism for the hydrothermal deactivation of
Fe-ZSM-5 which is dominated by three parallel processes: (i)
rapid dealumination of Brønsted sites (i.e., Al-OH-Si), (ii)
depletion of dimeric iron species, and (iii) migration of isolated
iron ions followed by dealumination.
23
The impact from loss of
active iron sites and Brønsted acidity on the SCR activity has
been thoroughly investigated, but no general conclusions have
been able to be drawn. Recent studies show that high numbers
of Brønsted acid sites are not required for high SCR
activity.
23,28
It has been concluded that NO oxidation is the
rate-determining step
3,29
in the SCR reaction at low temper-
atures where the reaction preferentially proceeds over the ion-
exchanged metal.
1,27
Devadas et al. showed that Fe
2
O
3
particles
Received: June 11, 2012
Revised: September 11, 2012
Accepted: September 12, 2012
Published: September 12, 2012
Article
pubs.acs.org/IECR
© 2012 American Chemical Society 12762 dx.doi.org/10.1021/ie301516z | Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2012, 51, 12762-12772