AUTEX Research Journal, Vol. 6, No 3, September 2006 © AUTEX
http://www.autexrj.org/No3-2006/0204.pdf
182
EVALUATING THE TOXICITY OF REACTIVE DYES AND FABRICS
WITH THE SPERMATOZOA MOTILITY INHIBITION TEST
Kaisa Klemola
1
, Ulla Honkalampi-Hämäläinen
2
, Jyrki Liesivuori
3
, John Pearson
4
,Pirjo
Lindström-Seppä
5
University of Kuopio, P.O.Box 1627, FIN-70211 Kuopio, Finland
University of Huddersfield, Queensgate, Huddersfield, HD1 3DH, UK
1
Institute of Applied Biotechnology; tel: + 358 505954178; e-mail: kaisa.klemola@designkuopio.fi
2
Institute of Applied Biotechnology; tel: +358 17163129; e-mail: ulla.honkalampi-hamalainen@uku.fi
3
Department of Pharmacology and Toxicology; e-mail: jyrki.liesivuori@uku.fi
4
Department of Design; tel: +44 1484 472054; e-mail: j.s.pearson@hud.ac.uk
5
Faculty of Medicine; e-mail: pirjo.lindstrom-seppa@uku.fi
Abstract
In this study, the toxicity of reactive dyes and dyed fabrics was investigated using
spermatozoa cells in vitro. Boar semen was exposed to different concentrations of
monochlorotriazinyl dyes: yellow, red and blue. The spermatozoa cells were also
exposed to extracts of dyed fabrics. After 24 and 72 hours respectively, the viability of the
cells was evaluated by microscopy. The mean inhibitor concentrations IC50, showing the
concentration of the dye when half of the cells are dead compared to the control sample,
were calculated from the viability values. After 24 hours’ exposure, the IC50 value
calculated for the yellow dye was 135μg/ml, and after 72 hours 60μg/ml. The IC50 value
for the red dye was 124μg/ml after 24 hours, and 46μg/ml after 72 hours. The IC50 value
for the blue dye after 24 hours was 127μg/ml. After 72 hours, the blue dye caused high
toxicity: more than half the cells were dead. Cotton fabrics dyed using these three
reactive dyestuffs were extracted by water and analysed by the spermatozoa motility
inhibition test. The viability of the cells when exposed to fabric extracts was good.
However, after 72 hours’ exposure, the standard deviation and coefficient of variation
values for cell viability of fabric extracts were large. The spermatozoa inhibition test
indicated the toxicity of pure dyes, the dyed fabrics having no adverse effects. The
spermatozoa test seems to be useful when screening different substances and when
used in addition to other tests. The spermatozoa motility inhibition test can be used for
textile material studies.
Key words:
textile, fabric, extract, reactive dye, monochlortriazinyl, toxicity, spermatozoa
Introduction
Textile manufacture utilises a wide range of chemicals which can be harmful to the environment, to
people working in textile processing and to consumers. There is information about the adverse effects
on textile workers and the effects of pure chemicals, but there is limited information about the overall
toxicity of dyed and finished materials [3]. Although a chemical itself may be toxic, its presence in the
finished material may have no adverse effect. To study the overall toxicity of textile chemicals and
fabrics, in vitro tests can be used. Spermatozoa cells have previously been used for studying the
purity of indoor building materials exposed to moisture damage [1]. Our laboratory also uses these
cells for studying the harmful effects on fibre-based food related materials. The in vitro spermatozoa
motility inhibition test is practical and cheap in laboratory work, and it has a good response to acute
toxicity.
Docker et al. [5] showed that 15% of workers handling reactive dyes had work-related respiratory and
nasal symptoms. Nilsson et al. [17] noticed that there were symptoms of asthma, rhinitis and
dermatitis in workers exposed to reactive dyes. Dyes containing anthraquinone or azo structures are
known to cause allergic contact dermatitis [7, 23]. However, it is noted that dermatological problems
associated with dyes in textiles occur relatively rarely. The cause of skin reactions is difficult to trace