Journal of The Electrochemical Society, 163 (8) A1619-A1626 (2016) A1619
0013-4651/2016/163(8)/A1619/8/$33.00 © The Electrochemical Society
D-Glucose Derived Nanospheric Hard Carbon Electrodes for
Room-Temperature Sodium-Ion Batteries
R. V¨ ali,
*
A. J¨ anes,
**, z
T. Thomberg,
**
and E. Lust
**
Institute of Chemistry, University of Tartu, 50411 Tartu, Estonia
Electrochemical performance of nanospheric glucose derived hard carbon based electrodes, specially derived from D-glucose via
hydrothermal carbonization and subsequent pyrolysis at 1100
◦
C, has been studied in 1 M NaClO
4
propylene carbonate electrolyte.
High Na
+
electroreduction and Na oxidation peaks were observed in cyclic voltammograms. Galvanostatic charge/discharge mea-
surements demonstrated high specific capacity, over 300 mAh g
−1
for the first cycle. After 200
th
cycle, a specific capacity of
160 mAh g
−1
(at 50 mA g
−1
cycling rate) has been calculated for the nanospheric hard carbon based half-cells. Raman spec-
troscopy, inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy data indicated accumulation
(adsorption/absorption) of Na onto/into the electrochemically polarized porous nanospheric hard carbon material. Impedance data
demonstrated that electrode potential has a noticeable influence on the total polarization, and charge transfer resistance as well as on
the mass transfer characteristics at the carbon|(1 M NaClO
4
+ propylene carbonate) electrolyte interface.
© 2016 The Electrochemical Society. [DOI: 10.1149/2.0771608jes] All rights reserved.
Manuscript submitted March 16, 2016; revised manuscript received May 20, 2016. Published June 1, 2016. This was Paper 512 from
the San Diego, California, Meeting of the Society, May 29-June 2, 2016.
Lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) have been studied and used exten-
sively for electric vehicle and smart grid applications.
1
Lithium (Li) is
the lightest metallic element and lithium electrochemistry has many
advantages such as wide voltage region (up to 4 V), high energy
density (250–730 Wh L
−1
), high specific power (approximately 250–
340 W kg
−1
) and superior shelf life over a wide temperature range
(−20 to 70
◦
C).
1–7
Li-ion small ionic radius is highly beneficial for
mass-transfer step kinetic characteristics, especially in layered solids.
However, limited availability and high cost of Li is an increasing con-
straint when these batteries are deployed and applied on a large scale.
Sodium-ion batteries are considered as promising alternative devices
to lithium-ion energy storage systems, since sodium (Na) is an abun-
dant and inexpensive element.
1
With growing global energy issues
in the 21
st
century, sodium-ion electrochemistry has emerged as an
attractive alternative energy storage technology to replace LIBs be-
cause of sodium abundance and inexpensive raw materials that lower
the production cost of sodium-based electrode materials and devices.
Sodium-ion batteries (NIBs) utilize similar electrode materials to
the ones employed in LIBs; however, the intercalation/accumulation
of Na-ion chemistry is slightly different because the Na
+
ion occupies
1.02 Å in an octahedral coordination site, which is larger than that
of Li
+
(0.76 Å in an octahedral coordination site).
2,3
The choice of
sodium is also favored from an electrochemical standpoint as it is char-
acterized by a highly negative redox potential and low electrochemical
equivalent (0.86 g (A h)
−1
).
1
While Na intercalation cathode materials
are gaining attention,
4–9
recent studies have focused on the system-
atic development of negative electrode materials.
10–13
Unlike lithium-
ion batteries, sodium-ion batteries cannot use graphite materials as
negative electrodes,
14
since the formation of binary graphite interca-
lation compounds is energetically unfavorable.
15,16
Metallic sodium
would be the best negative electrode in terms of theoretical capacity
(1166 mAh g
−1
),
17
but extensive dendrite formation during repeated
sodium deposition/dissolution steps is a major downside to its ap-
plication. However, recent studies of the SEI layer formation on Na
metal promise breakthroughs in the near future.
18,19
Among various anode (negative electrode) candidates, hard car-
bons have attracted the most attention for NIBs due to their high
capacity and relatively high (first) cycle coulombic efficiency.
20,21
However, it should be noted that about 60% of the capacity is con-
tributed by sodiation below 0.2 V vs Na
+
/Na.
22
Recent progress has
been made in terms of capacity and reversibility using commercial
hard carbons
23,24
such as hard carbons prepared from sugar
25
and
pyrolyzed biomass which have not been specifically developed for
∗
Electrochemical Society Student Member.
∗∗
Electrochemical Society Member.
z
E-mail: alar.janes@ut.ee
Na-ion batteries.
26
Specific surface area and optimal graphitization
degree are critical parameters that determine high reversible capacity
(more than 300 mAh g
−1
at C/10 after 120 cycles) and rate capability.
25
A porous hard carbon was used as the anode in sodium ion batteries
and exhibited good cycling and rate capability, delivering a moderate
capacity of 181 mAh g
−1
at 200 mA g
−1
after 220 cycles.
26
However, some non-carbonaceous materials such as metals and
metal alloys are highly promising electrode materials for NIBs due
to their high theoretical gravimetric capacity.
27
Unfortunately, they
undergo extensive volumetric changes during charging/discharging,
which limits their practical use in large-scale devices. Huang et al.
28
synthesized monodispersed hard carbon spherules (HCS) from an
abundant sucrose biomass, and investigated the influence of the car-
bonization temperature on the microstructure and electrochemical per-
formance of HCS. The initial coulombic efficiency of HCS was in-
creased up to 83% by coating its surface with soft carbon by pyrolysis
of toluene. The HCS carbonized at 1600
◦
C showed the highest capac-
ity (220 mAh g
−1
) with excellent short-term cycling performance and
capacity retention of 93% after 100 cycles. Ji et al.
29,30
developed a
graphene oxide-doping strategy for the synthesis of hard carbon with
a very low specific surface area. When evaluated as an anode for NIBs,
with a high active mass loading of 2.5 mg cm
−2
, they reported moder-
ate capacity, but one of the highest first-cycle coulombic efficiencies
of 83% for NIB carbon anodes (negative electrodes), compared to the
74% demonstrated by hard carbons (HC). Almost no capacity fad-
ing was observed (for 300 cycles) for sucrose/graphene oxide derived
hard carbon (G-HC), whereas with the conventional HC only 30% of
its initial capacity was reversible. When 10 wt% of carbon black was
added into the G-HC electrode, the desodiation capacity was increased
up to 280 mAh g
−1
, while maintaining high cycle life. According to
Pyo et al.,
31
the porosity and morphology of the sucrose-based hard
carbon (SHC) was regulated by varying the amount of bicarbonate
salts added during a two-stage sintering process. Reversible capaci-
ties of 324 and 289 mAh g
−1
were obtained for the first and 100
th
cycles at 20 mA g
−1
, respectively, in contrast to 251 and 213 mAh
g
−1
, calculated for SHC.
This paper proceeds to demonstrate that the specially designed
D-glucose derived hard carbon powder (GDHC), prepared via hy-
drothermal carbonization of 2 M D-(+)-glucose solution and sub-
sequent controlled pyrolysis, exhibits promising characteristics as a
negative electrode material for sodium ion batteries.
Experimental
Chemicals, reagents and experimental.—D-(+)-glucose
(≥99.5% purity, Sigma) was used without further purification for
the preparation of the 2 M D-glucose solution in ultrapure water
) unless CC License in place (see abstract). ecsdl.org/site/terms_use address. Redistribution subject to ECS terms of use (see 193.40.12.10 Downloaded on 2016-06-05 to IP