Application of Self-Organising Map Algorithm
for Analysis and Interpretation of Dissolved
Gases in Power Transformers
K.F. Thang R.K. Aggarvval
University of Bath University of Bath
Bath, BA27AY, UK Bath, BA27AY, UK
Abstracf Onset of incipient faults in power transformers can
degrade the mineral oil and cellulose insulation, leading to the
formation of dissolved gases. The process from oil sampling to
quantification of gases is known as dissolved gas analysis
(DGA). Despite the availability of DGA interpretation schemes
and artificial intelligence (AI) methods for transformer
condition monitoring (CM) based on DGA data, it is pointed
out in this paper that these approaches are less than ideal and
practical in implementation, In view of that, this paper
illustrates a novel approach for analysis and interpretation of
DGA data, which leads to a more credible CM of power
transformers. The proposed approach, which is based on the
self-organising map (SOM) algorithm, has been validated
using real fault-cases and thereby is proven to be more reliable
in portraying the current condition of power transformers.
Keywords: Incipient faults; Power transformer; Dissolved gas
analysis; Artificial intelligence; Condition monitoring; Self-
organising map.
I. INTRODUCTIC)N
Mineral oil in power transformcz-s consists of many
different hydrocarbon molecules, Electrical and thermal
faults can break-up bonds linking these molecules, which
lead to the formation of gases. For a slowly developing or
incipient fault, the gases formed will dissolve in oil, with
only a small proportion diffusing from the oil into any gas
phase above it,, This kind of fault can therefore be
monitored using dissolved gas analysis (DGA).
DGA requires the sampling of seven key gases as stated
in IEC 599 Standard [1], viz. carbon dioxide (C02), carbon
monoxide (CO), hydrogen (Ha), methane (CH4), ethane
(CJHJ, ethylene (C2HJ) and acetylene (CJH2), As described
in IEC 599 Standard, partial discharge (PD) occurs in the
case of low-level energy, such as breakdown in gas-filled
cavities resulting from incomplete oil-impregnation. In this
case, the major gas produced is H2. In other types of fault,
the decomposition of oil is mainly caused by heat.
Decomposition occurs at normal operating temperature,
producing mainly Hz and CH~. Higher decomposition
temperature, resulting from thermal fault (TF) such as hot-
spot and overheating, produces mainly CH4. With firther
increases in temperature, an increasing amount of C2H6and
CZH4 will be rsleased. In the case of a much higher
temperature resulting from disruptive faults such as
electrical discharges (ED), the production of C2H2becomes
A. J. McGrail D.G. Esp
The National Grid Company plc The National Grid Company plc
Featherhead, KT227ST, UK Wokingham,RG31 5BN, UK
significant. On the other hand, if cellulose materials such as
paper, pressboard etc. are involved at the location of the
fault, further gases, principally COZ and CO will also be
generated.
Owing to the credible relationship between the relative
composition of dissolved gases and the type and severity of
faults, several DGA interpretation schemes have been
established, such as the well-known Dornenburg Ratios [2],
Rogers Ratios [3], IEC Ratios [1] and Duval Triangle [4].
The implementation of these schemes, however, is less than
ideal since different diagnosis of fault is often result.
Attempts have been made to employ AI methods [5-9] for
improving fault diagnosis and condition monitoring (CM)
of power transformers. Although some of these approaches
are still dependent on DGA schemes for their development,
improvement over conventional schemes have been
reported.
A novel approach for analysis and interpretation of DGA
data is proposed in this paper, Unlike the above stated
methods, the proposed approach does not depend on DGA
interpretation schemes for its development; only measured
DGA data is needed. A brief description and comparison of
DGA interpretation schemes and currently available AI
methods for CM of power transformers is presented in first
part of the paper. The second part of the paper concentrates
on introducing the self-organizing map (SOM) algorithm,
outlining the proposed approach, and presenting the
performance and validation of the proposed approach.
II. REVIEW OF DGA SCHEMES AND AI
APPROACHES FOR CM OF POWER TRANSFORMERS
A. DGA Interpretation Schemes
Several well-known DGA schemes are, for example,
Dornenburg Ratios [2], Rogers Ratios [3], IEC Ratios [1]
and Duval Triangle [4]. These schemes have been
implemented, either in improvised or modified format, by
various power utilities throughout the world. The use of
these schemes requires the computation of several key-gas
ratios, as listed in Table 1. Fault diagnosis is achieved by
associating these ratios with a set of pre-defined faults or
conditions.
0-7803-7031-7/01/$10.00 (C) 2001 IEEE
0-7803-7173-9/01/$10.00 © 2001 IEEE 1881