359 Malcarne,etal:QualityoflifeinSSc
Personal non-commercial use only. The Journal of Rheumatology Copyright © 2007. All rights reserved.
Medical Signs and Symptoms Associated with
Disability, Pain, and Psychosocial Adjustment in
Systemic Sclerosis
VANESSAL. MALCARNE, INGUNN HANSDOTTIR,ANN McKINNEY, RENN UPCHURCH,
HELEN L. GREENBERGS, GRETCHEN H. HENSTORF, DANIEL E. FURST, PHILIP J. CLEMENTS,
and MICHAEL H. WEISMAN
ABSTRACT. Objective. Toexaminephysician-assessedmedicalsignsandpatient-reportedmedicalsymptomsascor-
relates of 3 quality of life (QOL) outcomes in patients with systemic sclerosis (SSc): disability, pain,
and psychosocial adjustment.
Methods. One hundred fourteen patients with SSc underwent a comprehensive clinical examination
including determination of skin thickening [Modified Rodnan Skin Score (MRSS)]. Patients reported
current symptoms and completed standardized questionnaires assessing disability and pain (Health
Assessment Questionnaire) and psychosocial adjustment (Psychosocial Adjustment to Illness Scale).
Regression analysis was used to examine physician-determined and patient-reported correlates of the 3
outcomes.
Results. MRSS was a significant correlate of all outcomes, although it explained only a small amount
ofthevarianceinpsychosocialadjustment.Patient-reportedpostprandialbloatingwasthestrongestcor-
relate of psychosocial adjustment, explaining more than twice as much variance as MRSS. After
accountingforMRSS,patient-reporteddependentedemasignificantlycorrelatedwithalloutcomes.For
disability, significant correlates were physician-determined joint tenderness and number of tender
points, and patient-reported joint pain on motion, joint contracture, extremity ulcers other than digital,
anddyspnea.Patient-reportedjointtendernesswassignificantlyassociatedwithpain.Regressionanaly-
sis supported a model in which disability and pain mediated the relationship between MRSS and psy-
chosocial adjustment.
Conclusion. Skin score is strongly associated with disability and pain, but only weakly associated with
psychosocial adjustment. Dependent edema has negative implications across quality-of-life outcomes.
Disability and pain mediate the relationship between disease severity and psychosocial adjustment to
disease. Assessment (including self-report of patient symptoms) of specific medical signs and symp-
toms may indicate SSc patients experiencing diminished QOL. (J Rheumatol 2007;34:359–67)
KeyIndexingTerms:
SCLERODERMA QUALITYOF LIFE PSYCHOSOCIALADAPTATION DISABILITY PAIN
FromtheDepartmentofPsychology,SanDiegoStateUniversity;
SDSU/UCSDJointDoctoralPrograminClinicalPsychology,SanDiego;
DivisionofRheumatology,DavidGeffenSchoolofMedicine,UCLA,Los
Angeles;DivisionofRheumatology,Cedars-SinaiMedicalCenter,Los
Angeles,California;andVirginiaMasonMedicalCenter,Seattle,
Washington,USA.
Supportedinpartbythegrant“PsychosocialandMedicalAspectsof
Scleroderma”fromtheNationalInstitutesofArthritisand
MusculoskeletalandSkinDiseases(5P60AR40770-04).
V.L.Malcarne,PhD,Professor;I.Hansdottir,PhD,Research
Psychologist;A.McKinney,MA,ResearchAssociate;R.Upchurch,MA,
DoctoralCandidate;H.L.Greenbergs,PhD,PostdoctoralFellow;
G.H.Henstorf,BA,ResearchAssociate;D.E.Furst,MD,Professorof
Medicine;P.J.Clements,MD,ProfessorofMedicine;M.H.Weisman,MD,
ProfessorofMedicine.
AddressreprintrequeststoDr.V.L.Malcarne,SDSU/UCSDJoint
DoctoralPrograminClinicalPsychology,6363AlvaradoCourt,Suite
103,SanDiego,CA92120-4913.E-mail:malcarne@psychology.sdsu.edu
AcceptedforpublicationSeptember29,2006.
Systemic sclerosis (SSc) is chronic, progressive, and debili-
tating, but until recently few studies have examined what spe-
cific features of the disease have the greatest influence on
health-related quality of life (QOL), or which patients are at
greatest risk for poor QOL outcomes
1,2
. QOL outcomes par-
ticularly relevant to SSc include disability, pain, and psy-
chosocial adjustment. Disability has received the most sys-
tematic study. Most studies have used the self-report Health
Assessment Questionnaire (HAQ)
3
or the scleroderma-modi-
fied HAQ (SHAQ)
4
, both of which yield a Disability Index
(HAQ-DI) that has been validated for SSc
4-13
. Generally,
patientswithdiffusecutaneousSSc(dcSSc)reportgreaterdis-
ability than patients with limited cutaneous SSc (lcSSc), and
more skin thickening (assessed by skin score) is associated
with greater disability
4,5,11,14-17
, although a recent French
study did not find these relationships
18
. Considering more
specific clinical signs, HAQ-DI has been shown to be related
to joint pain, swelling, and/or tenderness
4,5,7,8
, proximal mus-
cle weakness
5
, loss of hand mobility
5,11
, presence of tendon
friction rubs
5
, and heart/kidney involvement
4
. Two recent
studies have found digital ulcers are related to higher disabil-
ity
10,11
, although an earlier study did not find this relation-
www.jrheum.org Downloaded on April 16, 2022 from