Optik 123 (2012) 1287–1292
Contents lists available at SciVerse ScienceDirect
Optik
jou rnal homepage: www.elsevier.de/ijleo
Optimization towards reduction of efficiency droop in blue GaN/InGaN based
light emitting diodes
Sumitra Singh
∗
, Navin K. Rohila, Suchandan Pal, C. Dhanavantri
Optoelectronic Devices Group, Central Electronics Engineering Research Institute (Council of Scientific and Industrial Research), Pilani 333031, India
a r t i c l e i n f o
Article history:
Received 8 March 2011
Accepted 26 July 2011
Keywords:
Light-emitting diodes (LEDs)
Multi-quantum-well (MQW)
Efficiency droop
GaN/InGaN
a b s t r a c t
Light emitting diodes (LEDs) based on GaN/InGaN material suffer from efficiency droop at high current
injection levels. We propose multiple quantum well (MQW) GaN/InGaN LEDs by optimizing the bar-
rier thickness and high–low–high indium composition to reduce the efficiency droop. The simulation
results reflect a significant improvement in the efficiency droop by using barrier width of 10 nm and
high–low–high indium composition in MQW LED.
© 2011 Elsevier GmbH. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
In recent time, GaN/InGaN based LEDs have been commercial-
ized for indoor and outdoor lighting and displays, however, they
suffer from reduction in efficiency at relatively high injection cur-
rent levels, which has been named as the “efficiency droop” [1].
The quantum efficiency reaches its peak at low current density and
thereafter monotonically decreases for further increasing the drive
current [2–4]. The radiative recombination rate and output power
of the InGaN based LEDs are thus degraded accordingly [5]. Kim et
al. [2] reported the effect of polarization field in the active region
due to the lattice mismatch among InGaN well layers and GaN bar-
rier layers of the MQWs, which causes inadequate confinement of
electrons in the active region, and subsequently causes electron
overflow to the p-type region leading to an efficiency droop.
In addition, it has also been reported that at relatively high
current density, the carriers escape from indium localized states
and recombine non-radiatively in high-density defect sites [6,7].
The dependence of the dislocation density and the well thickness
on efficiency droop has also been reported as an explanation for
electron overflow as a major cause of efficiency droop [8,9].
Recently, the effect of the Auger recombination at high injection
current has been reported, which leads to the efficiency droop [10].
The reason to the essential Auger recombination presented may
come from the unusual Auger coefficient of the GaN-based mate-
rial, which varies from 1 × 10
-34
to 5.37 × 10
-28
cm
6
/s obtained
∗
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: sumitra@ceeri.ernet.in (S. Singh).
from experimental measurements and theoretical estimations [11].
A double-heterostructure has therefore been proposed as an active
layer to solve the problem [2,6]. However, the origin of efficiency
droop is still under debate.
One of the approaches to improve the overall efficiency of III-
nitride Blue LED is to reduce the electron overflowing problem [12]
by optimizing the blue LED structure. The III-nitride compound
semiconductors require relatively large injection currents (for their
operation due to lower hole concentration), higher series resistance
and lower material gain, ultimately making the electron overflow-
ing problem more serious than other compound semiconductors.
At present, incorporation of electron blocking layer (EBL) [13] is
known to be one of the most effective approaches in reducing this
problem. Moreover, it plays an important role in filling the pits,
which are initially caused by the lattice mismatch between GaN
and the sapphire substrate. The subsequent strained InGaN–GaN
MQW that is grown at relatively lower temperature (750
◦
C) would
further intensify density and/or size of the emerging pits [14]. To
improve the efficiency of MQW LEDs, EBL plays an important role
in confining electrons effectively in the MQW region [12]. The p-
type AlGaN EBL is usually used in blue LEDs to reduce the electron
leakage current. However, the p-type AlGaN layer also retards the
injection of holes, which leads to the degradation of efficiency at
higher current level. Yen et al. [15] suggested to use n-type AlGaN
layer below the active region and Kuo at al [16] suggested to use
InGaN barrier instead of traditional GaN barrier for reduction of
efficiency droop in InGaN/InGaN MQW LED.
In this paper, we have optimized an InGaN–GaN MQW blue
LED structure for the reduction of efficiency droop at relatively
higher current without using n-type AlGaN layer with the same
0030-4026/$ – see front matter © 2011 Elsevier GmbH. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.ijleo.2011.07.061