Journal of Namibian Studies, 23 (2018): 29 – 52 ISSN: 2197-5523 (online)
Copyright © 2018 Otjivanda Presse.Bochum ISSN 1863-5954 (print) ISSN 2197-5523 (online)
From German South West Africa to the Third Reich.
Testing the continuity thesis
Klaus Bachmann*
Abstract
The connections between the atrocities committed by German colonial forces in
German South West Africa and the mass murders perpetrated by Nazi Germany later
in Central and Eastern Europe have become an important aspect of the scholarly
debate about German colonialism. This article tests several elements of these
continuity claims: whether there was elite continuity between the Kaiserreich and the
Third Reich, whether formal and informal knowledge about the atrocities in the
German colony were available to and used by the Nazi elites and whether the former
German colonies played a role in foreign policy strategies of the Third Reich. The
author deems it more appropriate to speak about a rupture rather than continuity
between colonial elites and the Nazi movement, he argues, that formal knowledge
about colonial violence was hardly available to the Nazis and they did not even
consult the scarce institutional knowledge which would have been available. Informal
knowledge was available but tended to downplay or negate the atrocities and
therefore was unsuitable to inform policy makers of the Third Reich. Their main
objective in Southern Africa was to pull South Africa out of the British war effort,
rather than reconquering their former colonies.
Introduction
In 1904, the German colonial authorities reacted to uprisings of first the Herero and
then the Nama in the South West African colony by resorting to extreme violence.
1
After
the Schutztruppe, a special military force created for deployment in the German
colonies, had crushed the Herero uprising and forced the Herero to flee into the desert,
* Klaus Bachmann is professor of social sciences at SWPS University of Social Sciences and Humanities in
Warsaw, Poland. He also taught and researched at the Universities of Vienna, Bordeaux, Stellenbosch, at
Johns Hopkins University (Washington, D.C.) and Renmin University (Bejing). He has published on
contemporary Polish and German history and focusses on International Criminal Law and Transitional
Justice. His most recent book is Genocidal Empires. German Colonialism and the Third Reich, Frankfurt/M.,
Lang, 2018. E-mail: k.bachmann@feps.pl
1
The issue, which of the German actions during the wars against the Herero and Nama in German South
West Africa were genocidal according to critera of International Criminal Law, excedes the scope of this
article. It is dealt with in detail in: Klaus Bachmann, “Germany’s colonial policy in German South West Africa
in the light of international criminal law", Journal of Southern African Studies, 43 (2), 2017: 331-347, and in
Bachmann, Genocidal Empires. All actions, genocidal or not, are comprised in this article under the notion
of ‘extreme violence’.