7. C.F. Bohren, Light scattering by an optically active sphere, Chem Phys
Lett 29(1974), 458 – 462.
8. A. Lakhtakia, Beltrami fields in chiral media, World Scientific, Sin-
gapore, 1994.
9. D. Colton and R. Kress, Integral equation methods in scattering theory,
Wiley, New York, 1983.
10. G. Dassios and A.S. Fokas, Methods for solving elliptic PDE’s in
spherical coordinates, SIAM J Appl Math 68 (2008), 1080 –1096.
11. P.A. Martin, On the null-field equations for the exterior problems in
acoustics, Quart J Mech Appl Math 33 (1980), 385–396.
12. D. Colton and R. Kress, The unique solvability of the null field
equations of acoustics, Quart J Mech Appl Math 36 (1983), 87–95.
13. A. Bostro ¨m, Acoustic waves in a cylindrical duct with periodically
varying cross section, Wave Motion 5 (1983), 59 – 67.
14. A. Bostro ¨m, Passbands and stopbands for an electromagnetic
waveguide with a periodically varying cross section, IEEE Trans
Microwave Theory Tech 31 (1983), 752–756.
15. R.E. Kleinman, G.F. Roach, and S.E.G. Stro ¨ m, The null field equations
for the exterior problems of acoustics, Proc R Soc Lond A 394 (1984),
121–136.
16. A. Bostro ¨m, G. Kristensson, and S. Stro ¨m, Transformation properties
of plane, spherical and cylindrical scalar and vector wave functions, In:
V.V. Varadan, A. Lakhtakia, and V.K. Varadan, (Eds.), Field repre-
sentations and introduction to scattering, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1991,
pp. 165–210.
© 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
SLOW MICROWAVE WAVEGUIDE MADE
OF NEGATIVE PERMEABILITY
METAMATERIALS
Wentao T. Lu,
1
Savatore Savo,
1,2
B. Didier F. Casse,
1
and
Srinivas Sridhar
1
1
Electronic Materials Research Institute, Department of Physics,
Northeastern University, Boston, Massachusetts 02115;
Corresponding author: w.lu@neu.edu
2
CNR-INFM Coherentia, Department of Physics, University
“Federico II”, Napoli, Italy
Received 25 May 2009
ABSTRACT: The framework for designing a slow light waveguide
structure which operates in the GHz and up to THz frequencies is out-
lined. The design for the structure consists of a dielectric core layer
cladded with negative permeability metamaterials. The parameter space
for the metamaterial has been identified for the waveguide to stop light
and the negative permeability is achieved by split-ring resonator (SRR)
metallic elements. A prototype structure operating at 8.5 GHz is pro-
posed. Numerical simulations of electromagnetic waves interacting with
SRRs have been performed to extract scattering parameters and a pa-
rameter retrieval method has been used to verify the designed window
for negative permeability. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Microwave
Opt Technol Lett 51: 2705–2709, 2009; Published online in Wiley In-
terScience (www.interscience.wiley.com). DOI 10.1002/mop.24727
Key words: slow light; negative permeability metamaterials; guided
modes; split-ring resonators; parallel plate waveguide
1. INTRODUCTION
Recently there is a strong interest in slow light [1] for optical
buffers [2] and memories. This is partly driven by the progress in
optical integrated circuits where optical buffers are one of the most
important components. Without slow light architectures, only an
optical fiber with a length of a few kilometers can provide enough
delay time for optical networking switching. However in micro-
waves, the use of coaxial cable for wave delay is impractical due
to the much longer wavelength in the radio frequency (RF) and
microwave wavelengths. A long pulse delay is normally achieved
by electronic circuits. Nevertheless, it is still very desirable to have
RF and microwave delay lines without electronic circuits.
Slow light has been demonstrated in many systems by using
very different methods, such as the electromagnetic induced trans-
parency [3] and the coupled resonator structures [4, 5]. Slow light
in optical fibers has also been achieved [6]. Only very recently the
idea of using double-negative metamaterial (DNM) [7] as
waveguide core layer to slow down or stop light was proposed by
Tsakmakidis et al. [8] and the trapped rainbow phenomenon was
illustrated. The drawback with delay lines made of these types of
structures [8, 9] is the narrowness of the bandwidth of DNM,
which will yield a very small delay-bandwidth product [4]. The
scheme to design broad bandwidth slow light waveguide [10]
utilizing indefinite metamaterials [11] has been developed [12, 13].
It was also reported that other types of metamaterials such as
metallic gratings in THz range [14] can reduce the group velocity
by a factor of 10
3
–10
4
. Interestingly, the intrinsic loss in negative-
index metamaterials will render stopping light impossible [15, 16].
To avoid the difficulty of realizing DNM with small loss, slow
light waveguide with dielectric core layer and single-negative
metamaterial cladding was subsequently proposed [17]. This de-
sign of slow light waveguide also opens the door of using gain
media to compensate loss and bring light to a standstill possible.
The idea of electromagnetic metamaterials started in the field of
RF and microwaves with the so-called artificial dielectrics [18].
Active research on negative refraction [19] was fueled by the
realization of DNM by using split-ring resonators (SRR) [20] and
wires [21] structure in microwaves [22]. Thus, single-negative
metamaterials in microwaves is a natural platform to demonstrate
the realization of stopping light.
Microwaves are often guided in hollow or dielectric filled
waveguide cladded with metal. It is well known that near the cutoff
thickness or diameter, the group velocity of microwaves can be
very small. However, the problem is that at the cutoff thickness or
wavelength, both group velocity and phase velocity are zero,
leading to complete reflection.
In this article, we focus on trapping transverse electric (TE)
waves by using negative permeability metamaterials. We show
that zero group velocity can be realized at finite phase velocity.
The article is organized as follows: In Section 2, we give exact
solutions for guided TE modes in a planar waveguide and derive
the condition on parameter space for stopping light. In Section 3,
SRRs are designed to achieve negative permeability below 10
GHz. Numerical simulations on the SRRs were performed to
extract the effective permittivity and permeability. A prototype
slow-light microwave structure is theoretically proposed in Section
4. We conclude in Section 5.
2. TE MODES IN PLANAR WAVEGUIDE
We consider a two-dimensional (2D) structure which is formed by a
parallel plate waveguide (PPW). The vertical direction or the normal
to the PPW is along the y-direction. If the thickness of the PPW is h,
then for frequency below c/2h, the waveguide can only support TE
waves whose electric field is in the y-direction. For example for h =
1 cm, microwaves below 15 GHz will be only TE waves.
Therefore, we only need to consider TE wave propagation in
the xz-plane. We further consider a slab waveguide made of a
dielectric with
D
cladded by a negative permeability metamaterial
with
M
0 and
M
0 as shown in Figure 1. The dielectric
core layer has a thickness d in the x-direction. The guided mode
DOI 10.1002/mop MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 51, No. 11, November 2009 2705