© Kamla-Raj 2013 J Hum Ecol, 42(1): 9-16 (2013)
The Impact of Tourism Leakages on Local Economies:
A Case Study of Nyanga District, Zimbabwe
Leonard I. Chirenje
1
, Joseline Chitotombe
2
, Simbarashe Gukurume
3
, Bernard Chazovachii
4
and
Leonard Chitongo
5
1
Department of Social Ecology, Great Zimbabwe University, Zimbabwe
Mobile: +263777317205, E-mail: leonchirenje@yahoo.com
2
Department of Social Ecology, Great Zimbabwe University,
3
Department of Social Anthropology, Great Zimbabwe University,
4
Department of Rural and Urban Development, Great Zimbabwe University,
5
Department of Rural and Urban Development, Great Zimbabwe University
KEYWORDS Poverty Alleviation. Rural Livelihoods. Tourism Leakages. Tourism Employment. Community
Participation
ABSTRACT This paper examines the impact of tourism leakages on the local economies. It draws results from a
survey done in Nyanga District in Zimbabwe. Data were collected using questionnaires and in-depth interviews.
The quantitative analyses were employed to evaluate the level of leakages and its impact on local economies using
monetary values. Content analysis was used to summarize community perception of tourism contribution to local
economies. Results revealed that the most dominant type of leakage noted in the study area was internal/import
leakage followed by external leakage and pre-leakage. Out of USD $187 that is spent by each tourist in Nyanga per
day, the locals only get USD $24 which is 12. 83% and the rest, 87.17% goes to the service providers which are not
owned by the local people. The leakage of money out of the country was however relatively low. The paper
concludes that the low leakage out of the country is a result of limited number of international tourists. Reduction
of leakages can only be achieved through the creation of strong and sustainable linkages of ecotourism with the
other livelihood options, training local communities and strong local community participation in ecotourism
activities.
1. INTRODUCTION
The fundamental objective of this paper is
to examine the impact of leakages on local com-
munities in tourist resorts. Tourism can be a fea-
sible option for cushioning the local communi-
ties through the creation of direct and indirect
employment or encouraging environmental pro-
tection and conservation in areas where local
communities have low incomes (Hill 2005;
Scheyvens and Russell 2012; Synman 2012).
However, as noted by Fennel (2003), when eval-
uating the impact of money on the economy,
researchers must consider the multiplier effect
and the associated concept of leakage. Leakag-
es in tourism result when revenues obtained from
tourism economic activities in host countries are
not available for circulation or consumption of
goods and services in the same countries (Rah-
man 2012). There is growing evidence that most
of tourism receipts in developing countries have
no impact on local economies because they are
spent on imports or earned by foreign workers
or businesses, resulting in high leakages (Blake
et al. 2008). Diaz Benevides (2001) in Meyer (2007)
argues that higher rates of leakages ranging be-
tween 40–50% occur in most developing coun-
tries while lower rates of between 10–20% occur
in most advanced and diversified developing
countries. Tourism leakages tend to be highest
when the local community economy is weak and
fails to produce the quantity and quality of
goods and services demanded by the tourism
industry and thus it is particularly high in small
developing countries (Meyer 2007). If proposed
tourism development is not empathic to local
community’s needs, it will inevitably fail to sus-
tain the resource base that it markets to its tour-
ists (Loon and Polakow 2001). This study fo-
cuses on leakages in the tourism industry in Zim-
babwe with specific reference to Nyanga dis-
trict in Manicaland province. Local regions that
can minimise the amount of money leaving their
economy will have more of the initial expendi-
tures remaining to circulate in their economies
(Fennell 2003). In agreement Lindberg (1996) and
Lacher and Sanjay (2010) state that through iden-
tifying the leakages, or conversely the linkages
within the economy, the indirect and induced
impacts of tourism can be estimated. This is im-
perative for effective economic development of
marginalised regions in developing countries. It