83
Chin J Integr Med 2013 Feb;19(2):83-85
Historic Background
Chinese medicine (CM) has over 2,000 years of
history in China and was the only health care system
providing care for Chinese prior to the introduction of
Western medicine (WM) into China. WM was slowly
introduced into China by missionaries from the middle
17th century to the beginning of the 19th century.
By 1840, WM began to take root in China. Western
hospitals, clinics, medical schools and nursing schools
spread rapidly throughout the country. At that time, with
the might and power portrayed by Western countries,
everything "Western", including medical practices, was
believed to be "modern" and superior. Not surprisingly,
CM was rapidly abandoned, especially in the urban
centers. By the late 1910's, the new government in
power, with the aim of modernizing China, and with
the reasoning that WM was scientific and that CM
was not, set up rules and regulations to eliminate CM
altogether. Paradoxically, this actually turned out to be
beneficial for CM. Facing the risk of being eliminated,
CM physicians and their proponents were forced to
organize in order to protect, to develop, and to give
CM a more modern face. CM thought-leaders had the
foresight to recognize the need for changes if CM was
to survive and to progress. They began to foster the
idea of absorbing the strength of WM into CM, while
maintaining the essence of the Chinese medicine
tradition.
(1,2)
After the founding of the People's Republic
of China, Chairman MAO Ze-dong, noting that the
"subject of CM is a great treasure", called on doctors
of WM to learn CM. His thought was that "CM and WM
must combine … should study the laws of CM with the
modern scientific technique of the Western countries,
and thus develop a new medical science in China." In
other words, the theory of CM must be studied using
the Western scientific method.
By 1980, it became clear that there were three
forms of medical science and treatment available in
China: CM, WM and integrated medicine.
With this historic background, one could see that
integrated CM and WM may become a way to develop
and evaluate CM. Under this banner of integrated
medicine, much work has been done over the last 50
years, although much remains to be accomplished.
Concept of Integrated Medicine
Integrated medicine has been conceptualized
and defined in different ways. One can go back to
Chairman Mao's concept of studying the practices of
CM with WM scientific method, and thus development
of a new medical science. The most accepted current
concept and practice is to treat patients and illnesses
combining CM and WM modalities in the belief that
the two disciplines will complement each other. We
will use this commonly accepted concept and propose
a model for the future.
Integrated Medicine: Current Status and A
Proposed Model for the Future
We propose that CM and WM cannot be truly
integrated until CM has been proven to be effective
clinically. If well designed clinical trials cannot
demonstrate efficacy, there is little value in expending
efforts in trying to integrate the two disciplines.
We believe properly designed clinical trials which
demonstrate that CM is effective must be the first step in
a transition to integrated medicine. In order to develop
proper CM clinical trials, WM practitioners should be
reminded that CM theory and practice often have no
WM counterparts. For example, the term 'Kidney' (Shen),
is not the same as the anatomical organ described in
PERSPECTIVE
Integration of Chinese Medicine and Western Medicine in
Clinical Practice (Patient Care): Past, Present, and
A Proposed Model for the Future
Ian Tsang, Simon Huang, and Barry Koehler
©The Chinese Journal of Integrated Traditional and Western
Medicine Press and Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2013
Division of Rheumatology, Department of Medicine, University of
British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada
Correspondence to: Prof. Ian Tsang, E-mail: ianktsang@hotmail.
com
DOI: 10.1007/s11655-013-1350-9