Information, Data Entry, and Reporting Requirements
for a Resident Handoff of Care Support Tool
Ellen J. Bass
1
, Senior Member, IEEE, Kimberly Brantley
2
, Thomas Perez
3
, Matthew L. Bolton
4
, Adam Helms
5
,
Luther Bartelt
6
, Rick Hall
7
, George Hoke
6
, Margaret Plews-Ogan
6
, Linda Waggoner-Fountain
8
, Stephen Borowitz
8
1
College of Information Science and Technology, College of Nursing and Health Professions, Drexel University
2
Accruent
3
SRA International
4
Department of Mechanical & Industrial Engineering, University of Illinois at Chicago
5
Department of Internal Medicine, University of Michigan Health System
6
Department of Medicine, University of Virginia
7
Lee Moffitt Cancer Center
8
Department of Pediatrics, University of Virginia
Abstract— Physician handoff of care is a mechanism for
transferring patient information, responsibility, and authority
from one set of caregivers to another. At shift change at a
hospital, residents going off shift handoff patients to those coming
on shift. There are limited handoff of care tools that facilitate the
handover process by condensing patient information in reports
that can be referenced during the handoff of care and used
during patient care as cognitive artifacts. This effort works to
address information, data entry and reporting requirements for a
resident handoff of care tool that would support transfer of
information as well as patient care.
Keywords- continuity of care transitions, communications, quality
improvement, patient safety, sign-out, handover, shift change
I. INTRODUCTION
Improved automation such as health information
technology may improve patient safety and healthcare quality
as it can support human judgment and decision making
processes [6]. However, it can impacts health care providers’
physical and cognitive workflows by changing the way
activities are carried out and therefore can create new classes of
problems related to the coupling and dynamic interleaving of
humans and automated systems. At shift change, medical
residents going off shift handover patient responsibility and
authority to those coming on shift. Handoff of care tools have
been shown to help reduce the number of patients missed on
rounds and the number of adverse events [11][13][17][23]
although they depend on the timely and accurate data entry
[15]. Tools also offer the ability to print patient information
into different types of reports used as a reference during
handoff of care and when providing patient care [5][21]. Tools
have also contributed to satisfaction with handoff quality [17]
and efficiency in the amount of time pre-rounding and
rounding [17][23] as well as the amount of time spent at the
patient bedside [23].
There is no coherent set of requirements for these tools with
respect to the data elements to include for data entry and
reporting. In this effort an operational concept of tool was
defined based on literature about sign-out, observations of
subject matter experts, surveys, and an appreciative-inquiry
process (where exemplar residents met as a group, and a list of
practices for each of the residents was created and areas of
overlap identified)[12]. Requirements included the appropriate
data elements and functionality for data entry, manipulation,
and printing. Evaluation was performed via field-testing a set
of prototype tools, and determining if the requirements met the
needs of the residents with a combination of observations from
residents, surveys and review of logged data.
II. OPERATIONAL CONCEPT
The primary role of a handoff of care tool is to help
facilitate the handover process. A secondary role is to support
patient care post-handover. For patients in a resident’s patient
list, the tool should scaffold data entry for the information
pertinent to sign-out. The literature describes general categories
of patient information for supporting handoff of care (Table 1).
A resident must be able to view and modify data for his or
her patients. A resident should be able to populate a patient list
by adding new patients, reassigning existing patients from
other residents, or retrieving data previously stored. However,
the tool should not pull certain data elements such as the
current condition from prior hospitalizations, as it may not be
relevant to the current situation. In addition, the tool should not
pull medications, acuity, tasks, and some administrative
information such as location from the patient’s archived
information when the patient is readmitted.
Residents prefer to have a paper artifact to support the
handoff of care process as well as patient care
[5][8][11][20][22][24]. The printed report should format the
information to support the handoff of care process (Table 2).
For example, all of a patient’s data should fit on one sheet of
paper and not be across multiple sheets. Requiring this specific
report format helps a resident not miss any patient information
because it was on a separate page.
Residents may wish to control the order in which patients
appear in the report. One way to sort is by acuity with the
sickest patients first [2][10]. If something interrupts the handoff
of care session and it cannot resume, the residents will have
already discussed the sickest patients.
2013 IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics
978-1-4799-0652-9/13 $31.00 © 2013 IEEE
DOI
675
2013 IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics
978-1-4799-0652-9/13 $31.00 © 2013 IEEE
DOI 10.1109/SMC.2013.120
675