Indian J Dairy Sci 73(3): 260-267
260
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Choice modelling for participation in milk marketing channels: Evidence from
Punjab, India
Nidhi Singhal
1
, Harjit Kaur
1
, Pampa Mukherjee
2
and Santanu Basu
1,3
1
Dr. S.S. Bhatnagar University Institute of Chemical Engineering &
Technology, Panjab University, Chandigarh, India
2
Department of Political Science, Panjab University, Chandigarh
3
Department of Molecular Sciences, Swedish University of Agricultural
Sciences, P.O. Box 7015, SE-750 07, Uppsala, Sweden
Nidhi Singhal ()
Dr. S.S. Bhatnagar University Institute of Chemical Engineering &
Technology, Panjab University, Chandigarh, India
Email: nidhisinghal.25@gmail.com; Phone 8556962411
Received: 10 February 2020 / Accepted: 15 May 2020 / Published online: 12 July 2020
Indian Dairy Association (India) 2020 ©
Abstract: Over the last few decades India has witnessed
tremendous growth in the dairy sector giving varied market
opportunities to the milk producers. There have been growing
concerns regarding exclusion of the lower castes and small holder
producers from organised milk marketing channels. In this context,
the paper studies the choice of milk marketing channel in relation
to the demographic variables using a set of household level data
from the districts of Ludhiana and Moga districts in Malwa region
of Punjab. Choice modelling has been done using Bivariate Probit
Model and the econometric model has been operationalized using
software R. To overcome selection bias, a two-step analysis is
undertaken to explain participation in liquid milk markets and
conditioned on that is the choice of milk marketing channel. The
study found that Buffalo is the preferred milch animal in this
area. The region is dominated by organised milk marketing
channel with 69% households selling milk to the organised
channel. The study concludes that social barriers which are
manifested by caste of the household hamper the capability of
the SC households to participate in the organised milk marketing
channel.
Keywords: Bivariate probit model, Informal marketing channel,
Organised marketing channel
Introduction
From the shortage of milk in the country at the time of
independence (1947), India has since 1998 emerged as a top
ranking milk producing country in the world. At present India
produces almost 20% of the total liquid milk produced in the
world. According to GoI (2017), the country produced 165.4
million tonnes in 2016-17. Milk group is the biggest source of
income generation within the agricultural sector with an annual
output value of Rs. 416611 crore, which is nearer to the combined
value of cereals and pulses in the same period (CSO 2017). Milk
and milk products are also an important source of calorie and
protein intake for the significant vegetarian Indian population.
Between 2000-01 and 2011–12, the share of milk and milk products
in the monthly per capita food expenditure increased from 15.4%
to 18.7% in rural areas and from 18.9% to 20.3 % in urban areas
(GoI 2001; GoI 2012). India is thus witnessing tremendous growth
in the dairy sector due to rise in market demand, expanding urban
population, changing lifestyles, and increasing health
consciousness (Kumar et al. 2014). Due to formalization of Indian
dairy sector, food safety regulations are becoming increasingly
important in the dairy sector in India. These changes make market
access more difficult for the informal sector and encourage a
higher involvement of the private sector in organized milk
marketing. All these factors have contributed to creating a market
interest for the newer players in the dairy sector and are catalytic
in expansion of business operations of traditional cooperatives
and companies already in dairy business.
Since past three decades, dairy sector in the country transitioned
from protectionism to liberalization which led to the growth of
the private milk processors (Birthal et al. 2017). The state of
Punjab, the domain of our study and one of the most dairy-
developed states in India too witnessed this trend. (Appendix I).
By 2016-17, the milk processing capacity in the state increased to
more than 80 lakh litres per day by 2016-17 from 42 lakh litres per
day at the time of operation flood. A major part of the total milk
processing capacity, around 75% belongs to the private sector.
Consequently, the newly emerged dairy ecosystem is providing
more avenues to the farmers for selling milk at the village level.
With multiple players in the field, dairy sector is now witnessing
https://doi.org/10.33785/IJDS.2020.v73i03.012