Abstract—This paper presents synthesis methods and
performance measures for wire-actuated wrists using a
universal-joint constraining linkage. Performance measures
based on the isotropy of the wrench-closure workspace are
derived and used in generating design atlases as a function of
non-dimensional design parameters. The performance indices
that are optimized include wrench-closure workspace, isotropy
of the wrench-closure workspace, and kinematic conditioning
index. Stiffness is used to define a safety margin from
singularities of wrench closure. A design example of a wire-
actuated surgical wrist is presented and validated through
simulation. The methods presented in this paper are useful for
quick dimensional synthesis of wire-actuated wrists with
predefined wrench-closure workspaces.
I. INTRODUCTION
N many applications of minimally-invasive or non-
invasive surgery, increased miniaturization of surgical
wrists is essential to successfully performing surgeries in
restricted areas. Miniaturization permits increases in distal-
end dexterity as required for some surgeries. Another
advantage of miniaturization is the increase in the number of
surgical wrists and tools that can be employed without
increasing the number or size of access incisions.
Previous papers have proposed the use of wire-actuated
mechanisms in surgical applications. One of the major
advantages of wire-actuation in these applications is light
weight and small size [1]. It has also been proposed for high
lateral flexibility, which allows transmission of force to
hard-to-reach locations and through tight bending radii
[2][3].
Because surgical applications such as suturing often
require rotation about the output axis of the wrist, it is
necessary to include a constraining linkage which eliminates
unwanted degrees of freedom and allows torque
transmission along the wrist. Flexible, continuous-backbone
designs of wire-actuated wrists have been presented by [4],
[5], and others. A number of articulated designs are also
evident in the literature, which use rigid central linkages that
are capable of transmitting torque (e.g. [8], [9]). In [10] an
articulated design was presented that uses multiple universal
Manuscript received September 15, 2008.
Saleem Abdul Hamid (e-mail: sh2581@columbia.edu) and Nabil Simaan
(212-854-2957, e-mail: ns2236@columbia.edu) are with the department of
Mechanical Engineering, Columbia University, New York, NY 10027.
Saleem Abdul Hamid was supported from National Science Foundation
(NSF) under Engineering Research Center grant #EEC9731478 and by
Columbia University internal funds.
Corresponding author
joints in a parallel configuration.
Using a universal-joint as the constraining linkage enables
transmission of high torques at many tilt angles (unlike other
rigid central linkages) while providing very good lateral
stiffness (unlike flexible, continuous designs).
Unfortunately, the universal joint also has a number of
disadvantages that designers must be aware of. The uneven
transmission of torque [11] and the singularities associated
with some configurations at extreme tilt angles are the most
important of these disadvantages and will be explored
through wrench-closure workspace analysis in this paper. In
addition, the limitations of wire-actuation and the problems
associated with wire stiffness are addressed through the
formulation of design atlases and safety margins from
workspace boundaries. The goal of this paper is to offer an
easy reference for designers of wire-actuated, universal-joint
wrists to optimize designs for desired performance.
The analyses performed apply generally to universal-joint
wrists actuated by three wires. Because of this, the physical
feasibility of the mechanical design is not completely
resolved in this paper. It will be required of the individual
designer to determine if it is possible to actually
manufacture a design with the optimal parameters given and,
if not, iterate to a workable design that also has the required
performance. Also, since the design optimization is based on
purely kinematic considerations, this approach to design
may not be suitable for certain cases, especially miniature
wrists, in which stiffness, friction, and limited tolerances
play a critical role early in the design process.
Fig. 1. Example of a specific wire-actuated universal-joint wrist design
with the parameters used for analyzing generic wrists. The figure on the
right shows bending angle, and plane angle, .
Fig. 1 shows an example design and some of the relevant
dimensions of a general universal-joint wrist. The two
dimensionless parameters that will be optimized for the
various performance indices are the height over the top
diameter, ß, and the base diameter over the top diameter, ø.
The height for a general universal joint is defined as the
Design and Synthesis of Wire-Actuated
Universal-Joint Wrists for Surgical Applications
Saleem Abdul Hamid, Nabil Simaan
I
Height
D_bottom
D_top
2009 IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation
Kobe International Conference Center
Kobe, Japan, May 12-17, 2009
978-1-4244-2789-5/09/$25.00 ©2009 IEEE 1807