VOLUME 85, NUMBER 9 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 28 AUGUST 2000
Relating the Microscopic and Macroscopic Response of a Polymeric Fluid in a Shearing Flow
Hazen P. Babcock,
1
Douglas E. Smith,
1
Joe S. Hur,
2
Eric S. G. Shaqfeh,
2
and Steven Chu
1
1
Departments of Physics and Applied Physics, Stanford University, Stanford, California 94305
2
Department of Chemical Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, California 94305
(Received 9 March 2000)
The microscopic and macroscopic response of a polymer solution in start-up shear flow was investi-
gated using fluorescence microscopy of single molecules, bulk viscosity measurements, and Brownian
dynamics simulations. An overshoot in viscosity was observed upon flow inception and understood via
the observed molecular extension and by simulation findings. Increasing the polymer concentration up
to six times the overlap concentration (C
) has no effect on the character of the dynamics of individual
molecules.
PACS numbers: 83.10.Nn, 87.14.Gg, 87.15.–v
One of the most important goals in understanding com-
plex fluids is to link the macroscopic material proper-
ties with microscopic changes. For instance, interesting
macroscopic responses of these complex fluids containing
large molecules such as polymers, colloids, liquid crystals,
micelles, and surfactants have been widely reported in the
literature [1–7]. A classic example is the observation that
polymeric fluids often display a transient overshoot in vis-
cosity upon the inception of a shearing flow [5–7]. Various
theories and models predict such an overshoot [8–13] but
a clear understanding of how this macroscopic behavior is
associated with the changes in microscopic state is lacking.
In this work, we made detailed observations of both
the molecular dynamics and the macroscopic viscosity of
the same polymer solution. The effect of concentration
was studied down to nearly infinite dilution in order to
distinguish individual chain effects from those due to in-
termolecular interactions [14]. Finally, the experimental
data were compared to the predictions of molecular mod-
els specifically based on the known molecular parameters
of the polymer used in the experiments. We used DNA
solutions as a model system and made side-by-side com-
parison of the single-molecule observations, viscosity mea-
surements, and Brownian dynamics simulations.
Simple shear flow was created in a 50 mm gap be-
tween two parallel glass plates in an apparatus similar to
that used previously [15,16]. We measured the maximum
extension of the polymers in the flow direction (direc-
tion of plate travel) using video fluorescence microscopy.
The technique has been improved such that the transient
molecular extension could be observed in the center-of-
mass frame of a single molecule during the start-up of
shear flow. In order to visualize single molecule dynamics
at higher polymer concentrations, small fractions of fluo-
rescently labeled “probe” molecules were added to so-
lutions of unlabeled molecules [17–20]. To determine
the statistical properties of the molecular dynamics, these
measurements were repeated on an “ensemble” of 60 to
130 identical molecules for each different shear rate and
sample concentration. The time-dependent shear viscosity
of the same DNA solutions was measured using a rheome-
ter (RDA II, RSI Scientific, Piscataway, NJ).
By observing the recoil of isolated, stretched molecules
after the flow is turned off we measure the longest relaxa-
tion time, t , of our polymer [21]. The dimensionless pa-
rameter called the “Weissenberg Number” Wi is used to
characterize the effective strength of the shear flow. It is
the product gt where g, the shear rate, is the plate veloc-
ity divided by the gap width. In the simplest case of an
isolated chain, one generally expects the statistical prop-
erties of two data sets, even if they are taken at different
solvent viscosities, to match as long as Wi is the same for
both [15,22]. At higher concentrations one eventually ex-
pects to see deviations due to strong intermolecular inter-
actions (in particular, entanglements) which should change
the character of the dynamics.
First, we considered the limit of infinite dilution
in order to examine the polymer response in the
absence of any possible interactions between poly-
mer molecules. We used a concentration of 10
25
C
[23]. At this concentration the average distance between
molecules is much larger than the contour length of a
molecule and we expect interactions to be negligible.
When there is no applied flow, flexible polymers adopt a
random coil state. If a shear flow is suddenly applied the
polymers begin to stretch. While the individual polymers
display widely different dynamics upon flow inception,
the average extension rises smoothly to a constant steady
state value [Fig. (1)]. For Wi . 19, we observed a small
overshoot in extension.
In order to test whether the overshoot in extension was
due to an initial time synchronization of coiled molecules,
we compared the dynamics of coiled molecules stretch-
ing at the inception of flow to the dynamics of tran-
siently coiled chains after steady-state conditions had been
reached. We set the new time 0 point to be the first point
in the time trace after 50 strain units where the polymer
extension was less than one standard deviation from the
average extension at Wi 0. When these traces were
averaged together, there was no evidence of an overshoot.
2018 0031-9007 00 85(9) 2018(4)$15.00 © 2000 The American Physical Society