PHYSICAL REVIEW B 96, 174402 (2017)
Tunable magnetic vortex resonance in a potential well
P. Warnicke,
1 , *
P. Wohlhüter,
1, 2
A. K. Suszka,
1, 2
S. E. Stevenson,
1
L. J. Heyderman,
1, 2
and J. Raabe
1
1
Paul Scherrer Institute, 5232 Villigen PSI, Switzerland
2
Laboratory for Mesoscopic Systems, Department of Materials, ETH Zurich, 8093 Zurich, Switzerland
(Received 5 April 2017; revised manuscript received 23 September 2017; published 3 November 2017)
We use frequency-resolved x-ray microscopy to fully characterize the potential well of a magnetic vortex
in a soft ferromagnetic permalloy square. The vortex core is excited with magnetic broadband pulses and
simultaneously displaced with a static magnetic field. We observe a frequency increase (blueshift) in the gyrotropic
mode of the vortex core with increasing bias field. Supported by micromagnetic simulations, we show that this
frequency increase is accompanied by internal deformation of the vortex core. The ability to modify the inner
structure of the vortex core provides a mechanism to control the dynamics of magnetic vortices.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevB.96.174402
I. INTRODUCTION
The magnetic vortex [1,2] has generated wide interest due
to the rich physics associated with its complex nature and
promising functionality in spin-based technology. Although a
range of applications has been suggested such as information
storage [3], magnetic logic [4,5], and oscillators [6–8], the
fundamental properties of the vortex that govern its high-
frequency behavior are not fully understood.
In a ferromagnetic square, a well-known low-energy-
domain configuration is the Landau state, where spins circulate
around an out-of-plane vortex core to minimize magnetic
stray fields. The magnetostatic energy, which depends on
the position of the vortex core, can be summed up into an
effective potential, and displacing the core from its equilibrium
position creates magnetic charges along the edges of the
square and increases the magnetostatic energy. Inside the
potential, the lowest energy excitation is the gyrotropic mode
[9,10]. Experimental attempts to determine the potential of a
magnetic vortex using high-frequency excitations have so far
led to different conclusions. While the resonance frequency is
expected to remain largely unchanged in a harmonic potential
[11], observations of both a redshift [12] and a blueshift
[13] in the resonance frequency have been attributed to an
anharmonicity of the potential well.
Among methods to investigate the dynamic behavior
of the vortex, spectroscopic techniques [11,14] have been
employed to measure its characteristic frequency. Impedance
spectroscopy [11], for example, is usually performed on a large
number of structures due to its limited sensitivity and thereby
provides an average of the dynamic behavior. Anisotropic
magnetoresistance measurements [14] have been performed
on a single structure, thus avoiding the problem of averaging
over multiple structures with different spin configurations.
However, the high current densities required for effective
spin transfer induce thermal loads and Oersted fields within
the vortex that obscure a straightforward analysis. Magnetic
microscopy techniques making use of, for example, the
magneto-optic Kerr effect [15] or photoemission [16], provide
a direct measure of the spin configuration of the vortex, thus
*
peter.warnicke@psi.ch
allowing for direct determination of the vortex-core position.
However, up to now there has been no successful attempt to
quantify the potential well using magnetic imaging.
In this study, we map out the energy potential of the confined
vortex using spatially resolved broadband spectroscopy, which
allows the resonance frequency and displacement to be
determined with the same technique. This extended frequency-
resolved mode of scanning transmission x-ray microscopy
(STXM) was implemented at the X07DA/PolLux beamline
[17] at the Swiss Light Source using x-ray magnetic circular
dichroism (XMCD) as a contrast mechanism.
II. EXPERIMENT
Thin-film permalloy squares with a side length of b = 6 μm
were prepared by electron-beam lithography and lift-off pro-
cessing. Polycrystalline permalloy (Ni
80
Fe
20
) with a thickness
of h = 50 nm was sputtered onto 100-nm-thick silicon nitride
membranes and capped with 1 nm of Al to prevent rapid oxida-
tion. A stripline consisting of Ti(5 nm)/Cu(200 nm)/Ti(5 nm)
was subsequently patterned on top of the squares, and magnetic
microwave field excitations were generated in the sample with
currents transmitted through the stripline. An upper limit of
the magnetic field intensity in the sample was estimated from
the field μ
0
J/2w generated by a planar conductor where
w = 10 μm is the width of the stripline and J is the transmitted
current. The transmitted currents are measured at the output of
the stripline with a real-time oscilloscope. To allow for XMCD
measurements of the in-plane magnetization, the sample
normal is tilted 30° away from the incoming x-ray beam.
Temporal evolution of the magnetization is imaged via
time-resolved XMCD in a pump-probe scheme at the Ni
L
3
absorption edge (852.7 eV). Timing signals from the
synchrotron are used to lock an arbitrary function generator
with the data acquisition system [see Fig. 1(a)]. Current signals
from the generator are amplified and passed through the
stripline shown in Fig. 1(a), where the resulting magnetic
fields inductively excite the sample. The magnetic field
excitation is synchronized with the probing photon pulses
from the synchrotron. An acquisition system based on a
field-programmable gate array sorts the detector signal into
N time channels. Ultimately, the time resolution in this
experiment is limited by the width of the photon bunches of
2469-9950/2017/96(17)/174402(5) 174402-1 ©2017 American Physical Society