Behavioural Processes 75 (2007) 225–230
Short communication
Training and long-term memory of a novel food acquisition task in
a turtle (Pseudemys nelsoni)
Karen M. Davis
∗
, Gordon M. Burghardt
Department of Psychology, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN 37996-0900, USA
Abstract
We developed a shaping procedure for training Florida red-bellied cooters, Pseudemys nelsoni, to dislodge clear plastic bottles to obtain food
pellets. The animals were then trained in a 2-choice problem to choose only the bottle containing pellets. All nine turtles learned the task of knocking
over bottles for food. For the discrimination task, turtles chose the correct bottle 71% on average. After 2 months (82–84 days), and again after
another 7.5 months (228 days) of no interaction with the bottles, turtles were retested and many retained both the response and the discrimination
(mean success rates 77–81%), with significant savings in retraining all turtles. The turtles showed two basic response strategies, which changed
across time for some individuals. This study demonstrates that turtles can learn and retain a novel skill in a laboratory context.
© 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Discrimination task; Food acquisition; Long-term memory; Pseudemys nelsoni; Turtles
1. Introduction
The study of behavioral plasticity and cognitive processes in
diverse animals has been revitalized by the recent methods and
concepts of comparative cognition (e.g., Shettleworth, 1998).
Although reptiles as a group have been studied less than mam-
mals, birds and even fish (Shettleworth, 1998; Laland et al.,
2003), turtles have been used in more learning studies than
other reptile groups (see Burghardt, 1977, for review). Most of
these studies were conducted 30 or more years ago and focused
on visual discrimination abilities, documenting that turtles have
acute visual abilities and can be trained in a number of respon-
dent and instrumental learning tasks including visual and spatial
reversal learning (Kirk and Bitterman, 1963; Bitterman, 1964;
reviews in Burghardt, 1977; Morlock, 1989). More recently,
L´ opez et al. (2000, 2001) found that turtles’ spatial learning
and memory capabilities closely parallel those of mammals and
birds. Turtles share a common ancestor with birds and mam-
mals and are an important group for studying the evolution of
cognitive abilities in vertebrates.
Turtles are ideal subjects for instrumental conditioning and
discrimination tasks for several reasons. For example, turtles
will train for small food rewards more readily than many other
ectothermic reptiles (Burghardt, 1977; Kramer, 1989a). Fur-
∗
Corresponding author.
thermore, turtles (particularly many emydid turtles) are readily
available, adapt and perform well under captivity, and are long-
lived (Burghardt, 1977). Finally, turtles are highly visual, with
the ability to discriminate shapes and colors in stationary stim-
uli (e.g., Burghardt, 1977; Arnold and Neumeyer, 1987), which
makes them a favored group among reptiles for visual discrim-
ination learning tasks.
The study species, Florida red-bellied cooters, Pseudemys
nelsoni, are semi-aquatic emydid pond turtles found only in
Florida. They leave the water primarily to bask and, if female, to
lay eggs (Kramer, 1986). Agonistic behavior, courtship, forag-
ing, and other kinds of behavior have been studied in this species
in the field and captivity (Kramer, 1986, 1989a,b; Kramer and
Burghardt, 1998).
The goals of this research were to test whether turtles would
(1) learn to dislodge a clear barrier (a bottle) set outside the
water to obtain food, (2) learn to solve a discrimination task
(food versus no food) by dislodging the correct bottle, and (3)
retain the ability to perform the task over a long interval.
2. Materials and methods
2.1. Study subjects and test dates
Subjects consisted of nine Florida red-bellied cooters (P. nel-
soni) raised in captivity from eggs collected and hatched in 2000
from three lakes (Lakes Apopka, Griffin & Woodruff) in north
0376-6357/$ – see front matter © 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.beproc.2007.02.021