JAGS 51:32–37, 2003
© 2003 by the American Geriatrics Society 0002-8614/03/$15.00
Amnestic Behavior in Dementia: Symptoms to Assist
in Early Detection and Diagnosis
Rebecca E. Ready, PhD,* Brian R. Ott, MD,
†
and Janet Grace, PhD*
OBJECTIVES: This study evaluated two amnestic behav-
ior changes (repetitive questioning and repetitive actions)
to determine their utility in screening for early dementia.
DESIGN: Patient data were collected through a retrospec-
tive chart review. Comparison data from nondemented
older people were collected prospectively from acquain-
tances of clinic patients.
SETTING: The setting was a hospital-based outpatient
memory disorder clinic.
PARTICIPANTS: Participants were older individuals
with no cognitive impairment (n = 25), undetermined de-
mentia (n = 50), and definite dementia (n = 25). The un-
determined cases were followed for at least 1 year to assess
for conversion to dementia.
MEASUREMENTS: Amnestic behaviors were assessed
using informant-report for all participants. The behaviors
were examined for their ability to distinguish between def-
inite dementia cases and noncases. They were further eval-
uated for the ability to differentiate undetermined cases
that eventually converted to definite dementia from cases
that did not convert.
RESULTS: Results indicated that repetitive behaviors were
common in early and more-severe dementia cases. Repeti-
tive behaviors were relatively uncommon in cognitively in-
tact older participants. In analyses of the full study sample,
engagement in repetitive behaviors had high sensitivity
(0.97) in identifying dementia cases.
CONCLUSIONS: Assessing repetitive behaviors in pa-
tients may be a useful means for family members and pri-
mary care physicians to screen for early cognitive impair-
ment. The assessment can help to identify individuals that
should be evaluated further for dementia. J Am Geriatr
Soc 51:32–37, 2003.
Key words: dementia; mild cognitive impairment; screen-
ing test; amnestic behaviors; repetitive behavior
arly detection of dementia is critical as new therapies
are developed to alter the course of neurodegenerative
disease.
1
The American Academy of Neurology (AAN) re-
cently published guidelines to assist in the early detection of
Alzheimer’s disease (AD) by physicians.
2
The Alzheimer’s
Association also recently developed a list of warning signs
to assist patients and their families in determining when to
seek a complete dementia evaluation by a physician.
3
Included in guidelines for early detection of dementia
are changes in behavior. Behavior change is a common
consequence of neurodegenerative disease,
4,5
but specific
types of behavior changes are not well characterized. Bet-
ter identification of behavior changes associated with
memory loss that occur in early dementia would assist
family members in deciding when to bring a patient to a
physician for an examination. Primary care physicians
also would be assisted in identifying which patients should
be given a comprehensive evaluation for dementia, includ-
ing laboratory tests, neuroimaging, and neuropsychologi-
cal testing. Data indicate that a neuropsychological battery
of tests exhibits excellent sensitivity and specificity in diag-
nosing dementia,
2
but they are too lengthy and time con-
suming to administer to all patients. Thus, primary care
physicians need a screening test to better identify individu-
als at risk for dementia to whom current diagnostic tests
can be selectively administered.
6
Screening tests are simple,
cost-effective tests intended to identify patients who may
have a disease and thus should have high sensitivity.
1,7
Di-
agnostic tests are often lengthier and more costly tests that
are applied to individuals who screen positive on a screen-
ing test and are used to establish a diagnosis.
Questions about behavior change have not been eval-
uated as screens for early dementia. In contrast, several
cognitive screening tests for dementia have been evaluated.
For example, the clock-drawing test (CDT) has been
found to be a quick and easy measure that is useful as a
screening instrument in the detection of early dementia.
8,9
From the *Departments of Psychiatry and Human Behavior, and
†
Clinical
Neurosciences, Brown University School of Medicine, Pawtucket, Rhode
Island.
The project was supported by National Institutes of Health, National
Institute of Aging postdoctoral Fellowship 1F32AG20008-01 to RER.
Address correspondence to Rebecca E. Ready, PhD, Memorial Hospital of
Rhode Island, Medical Rehabilitation Department, 11 Brewster Street,
Pawtucket, RI 02860. E-mail: Rebecca_Ready@mhri.org
E