[Healthcare in Low-resource Settings 2013; 1:e22] [page 75]
Efficacy and safety
of Camosunate for the
treatment of uncomplicated
malaria in the University
of Benin Teaching Hospital,
Benin City, Nigeria
Damien Uyagu,
1
Augustine Omoigberale,
2
Paul Dienye
3
1
Department of Family Medicine,
University of Benin Teaching Hospital,
Benin City;
2
Department of Child Health,
University of Benin Teaching Hospital,
Benin City;
3
Department of Family
Medicine, University of Port Harcourt
Teaching Hospital, Port Harcourt, Nigeria
Abstract
In Nigeria, nearly 110 million clinical cases
of malaria are diagnosed per year, thus being a
major public health problem. The problems of
resistance resulted in the introduction of the
artemisinin based combinations (ACT) by the
WHO. Artesunate and amodiaquine (AS+AQ)
is at present the world’s second most widely
used ACT. This study is an assessment of the
efficacy and safety of Camosunate (a brand of
AS+AQ; Geneith Pharmaceutical Ltd., Oshodi,
Lagos) in the treatment of uncomplicated
malaria conducted at the University of Benin
Teaching Hospital (UBTH). A cross-sectional
assessment of the efficacy and safety of
Camosunate was conducted over a period of
one year using 120 patients selected after
stratification, by random sampling technique.
All recruited patients had slide-proven uncom-
plicated malaria and were followed up for 28
days on commencement of Camosunate. Data
was collected using a structured interviewer-
administered questionnaire and was analysed
using SPSS version 15. The overall efficacy of
Camosunate was found to be 95.8%. Treatment
was well tolerated as testified by the fact that
there was no case withdrawal due to adverse
drug reaction (ADR) or treatment emergent
signs and symptoms (TESS). Also no evidence
of toxicity was recorded. Camosunate is highly
efficacious and well tolerated in this area of
Nigeria and justifies its use as a first line
treatment for uncomplicated malaria.
Introduction
In Nigeria, nearly 110 million clinical cases
of malaria are diagnosed per year, translating
to about 50% of the adult population experienc-
ing at least one malaria episode per year, while
young children can have up to 2-4 attacks of
malaria annually,
1
accounting for 25% of
under-five mortality, 30% of childhood mortali-
ty and 11% of maternal mortality. Each year
70% of pregnant women suffer from malaria
resulting in anaemia in pregnancy, abortions,
stillbirths and low birth weight infants. The
disease also accounts for 50-60% of outpatient
consultations and 10-30% of overall hospital
admissions in Nigeria. In addition to the direct
health impact of malaria on the Nigerian pop-
ulation, the economic loss linked to the dis-
ease in this country is estimated to be about
132 billion Naira (around 878 million US $)
per year as treatment costs, loss of man-hour,
to mention but a few.
1,2
The disease is there-
fore a major public health problem in Nigeria.
Antimalarial chemotherapy has been the
primary option in the fight against this men-
ace. National drug efficacy trials conducted in
2002 in Nigeria demonstrated that the first
line treatments then employed, chloroquine
and sulphadoxine-pyrimethamine (SP) were
no longer adequate.
2
In 2005, the highly effica-
cious artemisinin-based combination therapy
was adopted as first-line treatment for uncom-
plicated malaria.
2
Artemisinin-based combina-
tion therapy has since then remained the
treatment of choice for uncomplicated
Plasmodium falciparum malaria in Nigeria
3
in
line with global trend, following the recom-
mendation of the World Health Organization
(WHO) to that effect.
4
Starting from February
2009, more than 80 countries worldwide
including Nigeria have adopted ACT as first-
line therapy.
3
Currently, five forms of ACT are
recommended by the WHO, of which all are
available in Nigeria. These include: i)
artemether and lumefantrine (AL); ii) arte-
sunate and amodiaquine (AS+AQ); iii) arte-
sunate and mefloquine (AS+MQ); iv) arte-
sunate and sulphadoxine-pyrimethamine
(AS+SP); v) dihydroartemisinin and piper-
aquine (DHA+PQP).
Artemisinin compounds – when used in
combination with longer acting antimalarial
drugs – rapidly reduce parasite densities to low
levels at a time when drug levels of the longer
acting drug are still maximal, thereby reducing
the likelihood of parasites being exposed to
suboptimal levels of the longer acting drug and
limiting the emergence of resistant strains.
5,6
The choice of ACT for a country or a region
depends on a number of considerations. A crit-
ical element is the level of underlying resist-
ance to the longer-acting partner drug in the
combination. This is particularly important for
AQ and SP in Africa, where both drugs have
been widely used as monotherapies.
The WHO recommends that countries use
ACTs, which are at least 90% effective, and
introduce new forms of ACT that are at least
95% effective after discounting reinfections
and that the Day 28 efficacy of respective part-
ner drugs alone should exceed 80%.
7
Concerns
have been raised over ACT including amodi-
aquine meeting such criteria in areas where it
has been widely used as monotherapy.
The efficacy and tolerability of AS+AQ has
been tested formally in several clinical trials in
different epidemiological African settings.
8-10
One of the AS+AQ brands in the country is
Camosunate by Geneith Pharmaceutical Ltd.
(Lagos, Oshodi). This study is an assessment
of the efficacy and safety of Camosunate in the
treatment of uncomplicated malaria conducted
at the University of Benin Teaching Hospital
(UBTH). Though similar studies have been
conducted in other parts of Africa including
Sub-Saharan Africa and Democratic Republic
of Congo,
8-10
none has been conducted using
the Camosunate brand of ACT in South
Nigeria to the best of our knowledge.
Materials and Methods
The study was conducted on patients
recruited from the Departments of Family
Healthcare in Low-resource Settings 2013; volume 1:e22
Correspondence: Paul Dienye, Department of
Family Medicine, University of Port Harcourt
Teaching Hospital, East-West Road, 6173 Port
Harcourt, Nigeria.
Tel./Fax: +234.8033.393806.
E-mail: pdienye@yahoo.com
Key words: uncomplicated malaria, Camosunate,
efficacy, safety, Nigeria.
Contributions: the authors contributed equally.
Funding: the drug samples used for this study
were donated by Geneith Pharmaceutical Ltd.
(Oshodi, Lagos), which also funded the laborato-
ry investigations. The company had no role in the
study design, data collection and analysis, or
preparation of this manuscript.
Acknowledgments: we are grateful to all the per-
sonnel of the Departments of Family Medicine
and Child Health of the University of Benin
Teaching Hospital who assisted the conduct of
this study. We also wish to thank the haematolo-
gist, microbiologist and chemical pathologist who
performed the laboratory analysis.
Received for publication: 28 March 2013.
Revision received: 14 May 2013.
Accepted for publication: 17 May 2013.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons
Attribution 3.0 License (by-nc 3.0).
©Copyright D. Uyagu et al., 2013
Licensee PAGEPress, Italy
Healthcare in Low-resource Settings 2013; 1:e22
doi:10.4081/hls.2013.e22
Non-commercial use only