Utopia Made Practical? Action Research Comes of Age
Bob Dick
Review Essay:
Peter Reason & Hilary Bradbury (Eds.) (2001). Handbook of Action
Research: Participative Inquiry and Practice. London: Sage, xiii + 468 pages,
ISBN 0 7619 6645 (hardcover) £75.-
Abstract: This large and important work gathers together an enormous variety of action research
processes, applications and skills in its 45 chapters. Following a useful section of chapter outlines
and an introduction by the editors, a section on "Groundings" offers a number of value and
epistemological positions. This is followed in turn by three other sections and a conclusion. "Prac-
tices" provides descriptions of many of the varieties of action research. "Exemplars" contains case
studies. "Skills" offers readers a glimpse of some of the competencies action researchers draw on
in their work. The quality of the individual chapters is high. In the introduction and conclusions the
editors describe their purpose, identify some themes, and offer a commentary which points towards
a way forward for action research. The result is a rich collation of current thinking about a family of
action oriented research approaches which is growing in popularity.
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Description
3. Major Themes
4. Themes for the Future
5. Minor Themes
6. Some Personal Reactions
7. Conclusions
References
Author
Citation
1. Introduction
As I write this, Western aircraft are raining destruction on Afghanistan in
retaliation for the tragedy of the World Trade Center. Against this backdrop it is
not difficult to understand the idealism and hints of utopianism which colour some
of the chapters of this valuable collection. At the same time it might easily be
thought that action research has promised much but has not yet delivered
enough to forestall such tragedies. It is perhaps understandable that a defensive
posture against modernist science can occasionally be discerned. [1]
But this is too narrow a view. What follows is a broader appreciation of the
handbook. I begin with a description of this large piece of work. Then, in turn, I
© 2002 FQS http://www.qualitative-research.net/fqs/
Forum Qualitative Sozialforschung / Forum: Qualitative Social Research (ISSN 1438-5627)
Volume 3, No. 1, Art. 22
January 2002
FORUM: QUALITATIVE
SOCIAL RESEARCH
SOZIALFORSCHUNG
Key words: action
research,
collaborative re-
search, emergent
research, theory,
practice, praxis,
emancipation,
participation,
relationships,
rigour, anti-
reductionism,
quality of research