The Biprimary Color System for E-Paper: Doubling Color Performance
Compared to RGBW
Sayantika Mukherjee and Jason Heikenfeld
Novel Devices Laboratory, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, 45221, USA
Nathan Smith, Mark Goulding, Claire Topping and Sarah Norman
Merck Chemicals Ltd. University Parkway, Southampton, UK.
Qin Liu and Laura Kramer
Hewlett Packard, Corvallis, Oregon, USA
Abstract: We demonstrate the “biprimary” color system
with dual particle electrophoretic dispersions and a 3-
electrode system. Preliminary contrast ratios reach 10:1.
Furthermore an electrokinetic cell is demonstrated
confirming basic functionality for EKD panels. A
theoretical pixel simulation confirms biprimary doubles the
color performance compared to RGBW pixels.
Introduction
Reflective displays or electronic paper aims to mimick the
same ability of print on paper, due to sunlight legibility,
low-power, light weight and improved compatibility with
roll-to-roll manufacturability
1
. However, out of all the
technologies that exist for reflective e-paper, none has been
able to provide bright colors without compromising
performance such as switching speed or pixel resolution,
which is the case for multilayer subtractive CMY
technologies
2,3
. Fast switching and high resolution
technologies tend to use the RGBW system which provides
saturated color at only 25% of the display area
4
. Hence,
there is a need for a new single-layer color system, which
acheives color performance similar to subtractive CMY
color without such significant compromises in other
performance metrics.
We demonstrate here the biprimary color system, which
utilizes both the RGB and CMY colors by grouping two
complimentary colors, one from each, such that they are
inside the same pixel. As demonstrated in Figure 1, the
pixel is divided into three subpixels and each subpixel is
dual-colored with one from the RGB additive primaries and
its complementary color in the CMY subtractive primaries.
Theoretically a high brightness white (W) state can be
achieved by clearing up the pigments and the black (K)
state can be achieved by fully mixing them. The
experimental demonstration utilizes electrophoretic
switching and two-particle complementary dispersions
developed by Merck
5
. Here we demonstrate the dual
particle complementary Green/Magenta (G/M) dispersion
5
in a simple interdigitated three electrode architecture, by
using controlled motion of the pigment particles. All the
four states of KWGM could be achieved with an initial
contrast ratio of 10:1. The same ink is also demonstrated in
a faster, two-electrode electrokinetic layout. The potential
of the other two biprimary pairs (R/C and B/Y) is similar,
and can be extrapolated from this work.
Figure 1: Diagrammatic representations of RGBW and
biprimary color systems, along with examples for display of
the colors W, G, and M. Calculations of theoretical reflection
(%R) and color-fraction (CF) are shown in (b, d).
Design and Operation
The dual particle ink dispersions are generic dyed
polymeric microparticles formulated and synthesized by
Merck Chemicals (known as EMD in North America).
They can synthesize dispersions by altering particle size,
charge, and surface functionality by using suitable dyes to
formulate combinations of two colored particles including
RGBCMY. They serve as a “ready to use” color
electrophoretic inks. The typical range of particles is from
60-1000 nm, we have used the G/M dispersion with the
green particles being negatively charged and the magenta
being positively charged. We have fabricated both 3 and 4
interdigitated electrode architectured devices to test the
G/M dispersion. The 3-electrode system has been used in
Late-News Paper 59.4L / S. Mukherjee
SID 2014 DIGEST • 869 ISSN 0097-966X/14/4502-0869-$1.00 © 2014 SID