Probabilistic spectrum superposition for response
analysis including the effects of soil-structure
interaction
I. D. Gupta
Earthquake Engineering Research Division, CWPRS, Pune-411024, lndia
M. D. Trifunae
Department of Civil Engineering, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA 90089,
USA
INTRODUCTION
The soil-structure interaction may have significant
influence on the dynamic response of structures,
depending upon the material properties of the soil
medium, the characteristics and shape of the foundation,
nature of seismic excitation, and the characteristics of the
structure. The translation and the rotation of the
foundation associated with ground compliance may lead
to a significant additional motion of the superstructure
that may account for a major part of the total response.
The inertial forces produced by such additional motion
of the foundation may cause appreciable deformations
in the structure (Wolf2S). For example, the analyses of
the results of the forced vibration tests on the nine-storey
reinforced concrete Millikan library building at California
Institute of Technology have indicated that more than
30% of the total deflection at the roof is associated with
the rigid-body motion of the foundation due to
soil-structure interaction (Foutch et al. 6, Luco et al. 19,
Wong et a/.27). Luco 16 showed that if inertial effects are
also included, more than 90% of roof response can be
attributed to soil-structure interaction. Results on
structural identification are also influenced significantly
by the interaction effects (McVerry 2°, Beck and
Jennings a, Moslem and Trifunac 14, Luco eta/. 17A8 etc.).
If the effects of the interaction are not considered, the
fixed base natural frequencies of the structure are
underestimated and the damping in the structure is
overestimated. Thus, the soil-structure interaction is an
important factor to be considered in the analysis of
structural response to strong-motion earthquake excitation.
For linear response analysis of structures with rigid
base the mode superposition method is often preferred
due to its simplicity. However, for deformable base,
decomposition into classical normal modes only is not
possible because of the dependence of foundation motion
on excitation frequencies, and because of the presence of
exponential mode shapes, which are not associated with
energy transfer into the structure (Todorovska et al. 22,
Todorovska and Lee 23, Todorovska and Trifunac24).
Nevertheless, some possible applications of the modal
analysis to interacting structure foundation systems have
been suggested by several workers. Tajimi 2~ has
Paper accepted October 1989. Discussion ends August 1990.
presented the equations for a building on a foundation
represented by frequency independent rotational and
horizontal springs in terms of the normal modes of the
building on a rigid-base. Jennings and Bielak 13 have
given an approximate solution for the response of a
multi-storey building with base disk having two degrees of
freedom in terms of the modified responses of one-degree-
of-freedom viscously damped linear oscillators resting on
rigid ground. For forced vibrations in the neighbourhood
of the first fixed-base natural frequency, Luco et al.18 have
expressed the relative displacement response in terms of
the fundamental fixed-base mode, and they have derived
approximate solutions for different response components
of interacting buildings. They have shown that the
calculated response from these approximate relations for
the Millikan library building is in excellent agreement
with the observed response. Chopra and Gutierrez 5 have
presented the methods for computing the frequency-
response of multi-storey buildings including
soil-structure interaction by expressing the relative
response in terms of the first few modes of the fixed-base
superstructure.
Gupta and Trifunac 7'12 have presented a new
stochastic approach for response spectrum superposition,
which can be used to compute the total relative response
of structures under simultaneous excitation by free-field
translational and rocking earthquake ground motion.
This approach can also provide the amplitudes of all the
significant peaks of the response, which is not possible
from other methods. In their study, the effects of the
soil-structure interaction are not considered. In this
paper, the formulation of Gupta and Trifunac 7'12 will be
generalized to include the effects of the soil-structure
interaction also. It has been assumed that the total
relative response, including the effects of the additional
translation and rocking of the foundation due to
deformation of the soil, can be expressed in terms of the
modes of the fixed-base structure. A simple three-storey
structure has been analysed to illustrate the application
of the presented method. The additional deformations at
various levels of the structure due to the interaction have
been evaluated for different properties of the foundation
soil, storey heights of the building and the aspect ratio
of the foundation slab. It is observed that the effects of
the interaction are more prominent for low values of the
© 1990Computational Mechanics Publications Probabilistic Engineering Mechanics, 1990, Vol. 5, No. 1 9