Space Code Design in Delay Diversity
Transmission for PSK Modulation
Meixia Tao and Roger S. Cheng
Center for Wireless Information Technology
Electrical & Electronic Engineering Department
The Hong Kong University of Science & Technology
Clear Water Bay, Kowloon, Hong Kong
Abstract— Delay diversity transmission is well-known as a simple and
efficient transmission scheme to exploit transmit diversity in wireless com-
munications. The interpretation of a spatial repetition code transmitted by
multiple antennas in a delayed fashion opens up the possibility of better
code design to enhance the performance. This paper considers the design
criteria fordifferent channel models. It is shown that all flat Rayleigh fad-
ing models, regardless of the time selectivity, share a common design cri-
terion, which is to maximize the minimum effective product distance. This
resultfurtherverifiestheflexibilityandrobustnessofdelaydiversitytrans-
mission. Nonbinaryspatialblockcodeconstructionisthenproposedovera
ringofintegersforPSKmodulation. Someoptimalsystematiclinearblock
codesareprovidedthroughexhaustivesearchforupto64PSKmodulation
and with up to 5 transmit antennas. Comparing with the repetition codes
employedinoriginaldelaydiversitytransmission,thenewlydesignedcodes
canachievesignificantcodingimprovementwithoutanyincreaseofdecod-
ingcomplexity.
I. I NTRODUCTION
In the last decade, a considerable amount of work has been
undertaken to combat fading by employing multiple transmit
and receive antennas in wireless communications. Receive
diversity essentially can be achieved using maximum-ratio-
combing (MRC). In contrast, transmit diversity is less straight-
forward to achieve.
Delay diversity (DD) transmission [1] [2] is a simple transmit
diversity scheme which transmits delayed copies of the informa-
tion signal sequence on multiple antennas. In this scheme, the
system with M transmit antennas is observed at the receiver as a
virtual single-transmit-antenna system with frequency-selective
fading of M taps. Thus transmit diversity of order M can be
achieved by equalizing the virtual channel through maximum
likelihood sequence estimator (MLSE)[3].
The original DD is proposed for flat fading channels. Recent
result [6] has shown that it can be easily extended to a frequency-
selective fading channel by increasing the delay step between
antennas from one symbol interval to L symbol intervals, where
L is the number of the actual channel taps. A combined antenna
diversity and frequency diversity of order ML can be achieved.
Since the invention of space-time coding (STC) [4], DD has
been interpreted as a class of space-time trellis codes (STTC)
and is referred to as delay diversity codes (DDC). It turns out
that the nice structure of DDC assures full rank but may not
maximize the determinant. The rank and the determinant quan-
tify the transmit antenna diversity order and the coding advan-
tage, respectively, in quasi-static flat Rayleigh fading channels
[4]. Another interesting way to interpret DD is to consider it as
This work is supported in part by the Hong Kong RGC. Emails of the authors
are: mxtao@ee.ust.hk, eecheng@ee.ust.hk
a spatial repetition code transmitted on different antennas in a
delayed fashion. Hence, carefully designed spatial block codes,
rather than repetition codes, should enhance the coding advan-
tage.
In this paper, we consider the design criteria of the spatial
block codes at high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) for different flat
Rayleigh fading channels. We show that design criterion for
rapid fading is the same as that for quasi-static fading [5], which
is to maximize the minimum effective product distance of the
block code. As the quasi-static fading and rapid fading are just
the two extremes of a practical time-varying fading channel, this
result implies that all flat Rayleigh fading channels, regardless of
the time-selectivity, share a common design criterion. In other
words, the best block code in DD designed for one channel is
also the best for any other channels. Having the design crite-
rion, we then consider the code construction, mainly for PSK
modulation. Notice that, both BPSK and QPSK modulations
have been studied in [5] based on permutation. However it is
not easy to extend this method to higher modulations. In this
paper, we propose a systematic linear block code construction
method based on modulo-P integer rings, with P being a non-
prime integer. Through exhaustive search, optimal systematic
linear block codes are found for up to 64PSK modulation and
with up to M =5 transmit antennas.
The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. In Sec-
tion II, we describe the system model of the generalized DD. In
Section III, we derive the common design criterion of the spatial
block codes used in DD over all flat Rayleigh fading channels.
Code construction, as well as some search results, are provided
in Section IV. In Section V, we provide some simulation results,
and draw some conclusions in Section VI.
II. SYSTEM MODEL
A. Transmitter
Fig. 1 depicts the simplified baseband system model for the
delay diversity scheme with M transmit antennas. The mod-
ulated information data sequence is denoted by {x[t]}. Each
information signal x[t] is first encoded by an (M, 1) block code
with output vector [x
1
[t],...,x
M
[t]] on the same constellation.
For systematic block code, we have x
1
[t]= x[t]. For repetition
code, we have x
m
[t]= x[t], for all m =1,...,M . To ensure
no loss of diversity gain, the minimum Hamming distance of the
(M, 1) block code should be M . This is also the sufficient con-
dition to achieve full diversity gain [5]. We shall emphasis it by
the following requirement.
0-7803-7467-3/02/$17.00 ©2002 IEEE. 444