Remediation Treatments and Economic
Assessment of Oil Residual Sludge
from the Bottom of Tunisian Refinery
Crude Oil Storage Tanks
Olfa Ben Said, Rihab Belgacem, Boudour Ben Gaffar,
Hamouda Beyrem, and James R Kahn
Abstract
The residual sludge from the bottom of refinery crude oil
storage tanks causes major environmental and societal
problems in Tunisia. Due to its high viscosity, it must be
removed from the storage tanks in order to utilize the
crude oil. However, its disposal in the environment leads
to the infiltration of toxic metals into groundwater and
eventual contamination of surface water bodies. The aim
of this work was to characterize and treat sludge from
Tunisian refinery by two different approaches (chemical
and biological) and evaluate the economic ef ficiency of
sludge remediation. Our results showed that both
approaches are useful in terms of reducing the metal
content of the sludge. However, the biological approach is
more economically ef ficient and leads to better ecological
outcomes.
Keywords
Sludge
Á
Petroleum
Á
Biological treatment
Á
Chemical treatment
Á
Metals
1 Introduction
With the accelerated development of the industrial sector,
humans are increasingly responsible for the pollution of the
environment to such an extent that scientists are now
labelling the current period as the Anthropocene [1]. The
diversity, the scale and range of production of the industrial
outputs have led to a considerable increase in the quantity of
waste. Petroleum activity, in particular, produces an
increasing amount of sludge in oil storage tanks which
threatens the environment and human health by the infil-
tration of toxic substances into the ground and consequently
into the water table [2]. This situation poses a real ecological
and social problem, due to the bad management of storage
and disposal. The spread of untreated crude oil residual on
agricultural land creates an economically and environmen-
tally irreversible problem. The strong persistence of the
metal contamination makes it environmentally irreversible,
requiring hundreds of years for the metals to break down.
The dispersal of the pollution makes the cost of
post-spreading treatment too high to remediate [3]. Hence
the economic and environmental need for adequate treatment
of sludge before spreading or landfilling. In order to reduce
the volumes of residues to be stored several treatment
methods have been applied including chemical and physical
treatment. The biological treatment alternative represents a
reliable, low cost and environmentally friendly technology
compared to the chemical and physical methods [4]. Sludge
treatment is one of the most complicated pollution abatement
processes with necessities and requirements of environ-
mental and public health concerns. The economic magnitude
of this problem is illustrated by the high cost of both
investment and operation. The present work aimed to char-
acterize the residual sludge from the bottom of an actual
crude oil storage tank of the Tunisian refinery “la Société
Tunisienne des Industries de Raf finage STIR”, to perform
remediation treatments to reduce metal and to evaluate the
sludge remediation economically.
2 Materials and Methods
2.1 Sludge Sampling, Characterization
and Remediation Treatments
STIR uses cylindrical tanks with floating covers to stabilize
stored oil. The sludge sample was taken from the bottom of
O. Ben Said (&) Á R. Belgacem Á B. Ben Gaffar Á H. Beyrem
Bizerte Faculty of Sciences, Environment Biomonitoring
Laboratory LBE, Bizerte, Tunisia
e-mail: nourelimen@yahoo.fr
J. R. Kahn
Department of Economics, Washington and Lee University,
Lexington, VA 24450, USA
© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2019
A. Kallel et al. (eds.), Recent Advances in Geo-Environmental Engineering, Geomechanics and Geotechnics,
and Geohazards, Advances in Science, Technology & Innovation, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-01665-4_19
81