Introduction
Chlorinated solvents are the most prevalent organic
contaminants found in ground water (Stroo et al. 2003), and
in the dissolved phase they are typically mobile and recal-
citrant, particularly trichloroethylene (TCE) and tetra-
chloroethylene (PCE). Schwille (1984, 1988) was the first
to recognize that chlorinated solvent plumes (i.e., zones of
dissolved phase contaminants) are caused by immobile
dense nonaqueous phase liquid (DNAPL) zones within the
ground water. Ground water flowing through the DNAPL
zones causes DNAPL dissolution, generating plumes that
commonly achieve exceptionally large sizes relative to
plumes comprised of other types of organic contaminants
(Mackay and Cherry 1989). Although the processes gov-
erning subsurface DNAPL and plume behavior are known
(Cohen and Mercer 1993; Pankow and Cherry 1996) and
numerous solvent contaminated sites have been investi-
gated, DNAPL masses at field sites are not often quantified.
(Feenstra 2003). Heterogeneity imposes severe limits for
measuring DNAPL mass; however, determining the rate of
dissolved-phase mass lost from DNAPL zones due to dis-
solution and ground water transport is a much more feasi-
ble endeavor.
In recent years, determining the discharge of the dis-
solved-phase mass emanating from DNAPL and other
types of source zones has become important (Ptak et al.
1998; Einarson and Mackay 2001). Feenstra et al. (1996)
defined the plume discharge as the amount of contaminant
mass migrating through cross sections of the aquifer
orthogonal to ground water flow per unit of time. The
plume discharge measured on an orthogonal cross section
(i.e., vertical control plane) positioned immediately down-
gradient of the source area is an important quantity for
assessing plume impacts on water supply wells (Einarson
Abstract
At three industrial sites in Ontario, New Hampshire, and Florida, tetrachloroethylene (PCE) and trichloroethyl-
ene (TCE), released decades ago as dense nonaqueous phase liquids (DNAPLs), now form persistent source zones
for dissolved contaminant plumes. These zones are suspended below the water table and above the bottoms of their
respective, moderately homogeneous, unconfined sandy aquifers. Exceptionally detailed, depth-discrete, ground
water sampling was performed using a direct-push sampler along cross sections of the dissolved-phase plumes, imme-
diately downgradient of these DNAPL source zones. The total plume PCE or TCE mass-discharge through each cross
section ranged between 15 and 31 kg/year. Vertical ground water sample spacing as small as 15 cm and lateral spac-
ing typically between 1 and 3 m revealed small zones where maximum concentrations were between 1% and 61% of
solubility. These local maxima are surrounded by much lower concentration zones. A spacing no larger than 15 to 30
cm was needed at some locations to identify high concentration zones, and aqueous VOC concentrations varied as
much as four orders of magnitude across 30 cm vertical intervals. High-resolution sampling at these sites showed that
three-quarters of the mass-discharge occurs within 5% to 10% of the plume cross sectional areas. The extreme spa-
tial variability of the mass-discharge occurs even though the sand aquifers are nearly hydraulically homogeneous.
Depth-discrete field techniques such as those used in this study are essential for finding the small zones producing
most of the mass-discharge, which is important for assessing natural attenuation and designing remedial options.
70
Mass and Flux Distributions from
DNAPL Zones in Sandy Aquifers
by Martin A. Guilbeault
1,2
, Beth L. Parker
1,3
, and John A. Cherry
1
1
Department of Earth Sciences, University of Waterloo,
Waterloo, Ontario N2L 3G1 Canada
2
Now at Gartner Lee Ltd., 2251–2nd Ave., Whitehorse, Yukon
Y1A 5W1 Canada
3
Corresponding author: (519) 888–4567 ext. 5371; fax (519)
883–0220; blparker@uwaterloo.ca
Received September 2003, accepted March 2004.
Copyright © 2005 by the National Ground Water Association.
Vol. 43, No. 1—GROUND WATER—January–February 2005 (pages 70–86)