VOL. 12, NO. 19, OCTOBER 2017 ISSN 1819-6608
ARPN Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences
©2006-2017 Asian Research Publishing Network (ARPN). All rights reserved.
www.arpnjournals.com
5642
MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR CALCULATING SCALLOP HEIGHT
OF TOROIDAL CUTTER IN FIVE-AXIS MILLING
Hendriko Hendriko
Politeknik Caltex Riau, Pekanbaru, Riau Indonesia
E-Mail: hendriko@pcr.ac.id
ABSTRACT
The scallop height is the most substantial variable in determining the quality of machined surface. Many
analytical approacheswere proposed to calculated the scallop height infive-axis milling.Most of them addressed the issue of
scallop height for toroidal cutter by approximating the inclined cutting tool using two common primitive geometries, either
circle or ellipse.This paper presents an analytical method to calculate the scallop height of toroidal cutter produced by
predefined tool path in five-axis milling. The present study was aimed to improve the drawback of the existing method in
representing the swept curve of inclined toroidal cutter. In this study, the swept curve was calculated analytically by
adopting the method to calculate the grazing point in swept envelope development. The coordinate of intersection point
was calculated by using the combination of swept curve algorithm and coordinate mapping equations. The proposed
method was successfully used to generate scallop height data for two machining processes with different step over.
Keywords: scallop height, toroidal cutter, grazing toroidal approximation, five-axis milling.
1. INTRODUCTION
Many products, such as mould and dies, are
designed with free-form surfaces. Currently, those part
surfaces are often produced by five-axis milling.
Theoretically, five-axis milling offers better efficiency
than three-axis milling in producing complex part surface.
In five-axis milling, the tool orientation relative to the
workpiece can be controlled by two additional degrees of
freedom. However, the additional degrees of freedom
created complexity as well as flexibility compared to
three-axis milling.
Machining free-form part is normally involving a
huge number of tool movements. Consequently, it is both
a long and costly process. Considering the time needed for
finishing and polishing which could consume as much as
75% of the total machining time [1], therefore, selecting
and controlling the cutting conditions and the strategies
employed to increase product quality become very
important.
In general, there are three parameters that are
commonly used to control the accuracy of the machined
surface: 1) machining tolerance, 2) scallop height, and 3)
surface roughness. In multi-axis milling, scallop height
becomes the most substantial component in determining
the quality of mahined surface. It is influenced by four
factors, 1) cutting tool geometry, 2) tool orientation, 3)
part surface geometry, and 4) the distance between
adjacent tool path (step over). In order to achieve the
expected surface quality, the scallop must be well
controlled. However, due to the complexity of the part
surface and tool orientation, scallop height is difficult to
calculate and it cannot be represented easily. In developing
tool path for free-form surfaces, the method to determine
the scallop height accurately is still a major challenge.
Many studies developed the method to calculate
the scallop height during sculptured surface machining.
Most of the proposed method calculated the scallop height
usinganalytical approaches. Analytical approachwas used
to calculate the cut geometry and scallop height in five
axis milling because it was much faster and more accurate
when compared to the discrete approaches [2-4]. Several
researchers [5-8] have performed the study on the
effectiveness of inclined flat end mills in the machining of
curved surfaces. The results show that flat-end mill
produces smaller scallops as compared to ball-end mill.
Other studies [9-13] proposed method for calculating the
scallop height for ball-end mill to achieve optimal tool
path. Ozturk et al. [14] investigated the effect of tool
orientation to the scallop height in five-axis milling.
Meanwhile [8, 13,15] addressed the issue of scallop height
for toroidal cutter by simply assumed that the curvature
was constant and cutter geometry was approximated by
two common primitive geometry, either circle or ellipse.
Senatore et al. [10] represented the tool swept
envelope by calculating the effective radius of toroidal
cutter due to the inclination angle. Then the scallop height
with respect to radius of part surface was calculated and
finally the optimal step over can be determined. Others
studies [5-12, 15, 16] defined the inclined flat and ball end
mills as an ellipse. Mathematically, the shape of swept
curves (SV) of inclined flat and ball end mill, which are
projected into 2D, can be precisely determined by
parametric equation of ellipse curve. However, this
approach is not applicable to toroidal cutter. Toroidal
cutter is decomposed into cylindrical surface and toroidal
surface, consequently, determining the swept curve when
the inclination angle existsbecomes much more
complicated. This statement will be prooved in the section
of Implementation and Discussion.
This paper presents an analytical method to
calculate the scallop height of toroidal cutter produced by
predefined tool path in five-axis milling. The present study
was addressed to improve the drawback of the existing
method in representing the swept curve of inclined
toroidal cutter. In this study, the swept curve was
calculated analytically by adopting the method to calculate
the grazing point in swept envelope development. The
coordinate of intersection point was calculated by using