The Long-term Effects of
Disturbance on Organic and
Inorganic Nitrogen Export in the
White Mountains, New Hampshire
Christine L. Goodale,
1
* John D. Aber,
1
and William H. McDowell
2
1
Complex Systems Research Center, University of New Hampshire, Durham, New Hampshire 03824, USA; and
2
Department of
Natural Resources, University of New Hampshire, Durham, New Hampshire 03824, USA
ABSTRACT
Traditional biogeochemical theories suggest that
ecosystem nitrogen retention is controlled by biotic
N limitation, that stream N losses should increase
with successional age, and that increasing N depo-
sition will accelerate this process. These theories
ignore the role of dissolved organic nitrogen (DON)
as a mechanism of N loss. We examined patterns of
organic and inorganic N export from sets of old-
growth and historically (80 –110 years ago) logged
and burned watersheds in the northeastern US, a
region of moderate, elevated N deposition. Stream
nitrate concentrations were strongly seasonal, and
mean ( SD) nitrate export from old-growth wa-
tersheds (1.4 0.6 kg N ha
-1
y
-1
) was four times
greater than from disturbed watersheds (0.3 0.3
kg N ha
-1
y
-1
), suggesting that biotic control over
nitrate loss can persist for a century. DON loss av-
eraged 0.7 ( 0.2) kg N ha
-1
y
-1
and accounted for
28 – 87% of total dissolved N (TDN) export. DON
concentrations did not vary seasonally or with suc-
cessional status, but correlated with dissolved or-
ganic carbon (DOC), which varied inversely with
hardwood forest cover. The patterns of DON loss
did not follow expected differences in biotic N de-
mand but instead were consistent with expected
differences in DOC production and sorption. De-
spite decades of moderate N deposition, TDN export
was low, and even old-growth forests retained at
least 65% of N inputs. The reasons for this high N
retention are unclear: if due to a large capacity for N
storage or biological removal, N saturation may re-
quire several decades to occur; if due to interannual
climate variability, large losses of nitrate may occur
much sooner.
Key words: disturbance; dissolved organic carbon;
dissolved organic nitrogen; fire; logging; nitrate
leaching; nitrogen saturation; nitrogen retention;
old growth; succession.
INTRODUCTION
Human activities have vastly changed the global
nitrogen (N) cycle (Galloway and others 1995; Vi-
tousek and others 1997). Nitrogen deposition to the
eastern United States has increased at least five- to
10-fold since preindustrial times, and even higher N
deposition rates occur in western Europe (Galloway
and others 1995; Holland and others 1999). In or-
der to anticipate the downstream consequences of
this large change in N inputs, it is important to
understand the mechanisms that control ecosystem
N retention. Traditional biogeochemical theories
suggest that ecosystem N losses are controlled by
varying degrees of biotic N limitation, with N losses
increasing as N availability exceeds plant and mi-
crobial demand. Essentially:
Received 27 April 1999; accepted 30 May 2000.
*Corresponding author’s current address: Carnegie Institution of Washington,
Department of Plant Biology, 260 Panama St., Stanford, California 94305,
USA; e-mail: christy@jasper.stanford.edu
Ecosystems (2000) 3: 433– 450
DOI: 10.1007/s100210000039
ECOSYSTEMS
© 2000 Springer-Verlag
433